What Are Your Views on Crowdfunding Through Sites Like Kickstarter? [You Told Us]

Dave Parrack 03-07-2013

What Are Your Views on Crowdfunding Through Sites Like Kickstarter? [You Told Us] you told us111Crowdfunding is becoming a legitimate tool for inventors, merchants, and creative people to raise money for their wares. Whether it’s the funds needed to mass-produce a new piece of hardware, or the funds needed to take a year off in order to write a book, sites such as Kickstarter and Indiegogo offer people a new way of raising money from the public.


Using Ouya Learn All About Ouya, The $99 Games Console Read More , the $99, Android-powered, emulator-ready games console, as an example of both the positive and negative sides of crowdfunding, we asked for your views on the phenomenon. Crowdfunding seems set to keep on growing, so gaining an insight into how the MakeUseOf readership thinks about it all was a good idea, or so we thought.

The Results

We asked you, What Are Your Views On Crowdfunding Through Sites Like Kickstarter?I’m ashamed to say we only had five people contribute to the debate. Whether this was down to the choice of subject matter, the overlong and (potentially) confusing title, or the offer of a T-shirt to the best comment of the week not being enough motivation to bother, isn’t clear. But it’s a shame nonetheless.

What Are Your Views on Crowdfunding Through Sites Like Kickstarter? [You Told Us] crowdfunding graphic

With so few people contributing their views to the discussion it’s impossible to reach any kind of consensus. Instead we’ll look in closer detail at a few of the points raised:

  • Backers invest in an idea with more than just money, feeling they’ve become part of something from the beginning. Unfortunately this means any perceived wrongdoing from the people behind the project causes frustration and confusion.
  • As well as adding investors, a crowdfunding project offers a form of market research. If a project fails then the idea just may not be good enough, and if it succeeds beyond all expectations then the creator’s passion is rewarded.
  • Crowdfunding offers a viable alternative to the usual forms of business. It cuts banks and money lenders out of the equation, and lets creative people operate freely without the need to be acquired and/or marketed by an agent or publisher.

Comment Of The Week

With so few commenters taking part in the debate, everyone who did take the time and effort to comment is getting a namecheck. We had great input from SH, dragonmouth, Derek, and Junil Maharjan. Comment Of The Week goes to Leland Whitlock, who won with this comment:


I have read a lot about Kickstarter and similar sites recently. One of the themes was how rich people often get pushed to give lots on these projects so avoid any bad press or what not. But on the other side of it you have some genuinely great ideas from people with few resources and this gives those people a great platform to take those ideas and fly with them turning dreams into reality. Kind of like the old idea of America being the land of opportunity. So overall I think it is a great platform but the people giving need to realize these ideas are a business opportunity and the ones doing the campaign are trying to start a business not be friends. For giving we might get an early model or just updates on the project based on what we give. We should not expect more. Also as with any business there are lots of things that can go wrong and often when trying to launch a product you don’t have time for much else. We all need to be patient and not judge to harshly as long as we get whatever was promised.

We will be asking a new question tomorrow, so please join us then. We Ask You is a weekly column dedicated to finding out the opinions of MakeUseOf readers. We ask you a question and you tell us what you think. The question is open-ended and is usually open to debate. Some questions will be purely opinion-based, while others will see you sharing tips and advice, or advocating tools and apps to the MakeUseOf readership. This column is nothing without your input, all of which is valued.

Image Credit: Rocio Lara

Affiliate Disclosure: By buying the products we recommend, you help keep the site alive. Read more.

Whatsapp Pinterest

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Robert B
    July 16, 2013 at 8:24 pm

    Perhaps the reason for such a low comment rate for this article has nothing to do with the topic and everything to do with the topic. Too many people today are being squeezed very tightly by poor economic times, too few available jobs and not even enough money at the end of the day to even take care of ones family. I would venture a guess that the vast majority have not even given this topic a second thought because they know that they don't have the means to participate even in a modest way.

  2. Vishal S
    July 3, 2013 at 12:47 pm

    I'm sorry I didn't comment on it before. I'd like to present my views. I'm taking a Coursera course on Startup Engineering. The origin on crowd funding, according to me is the need for businesses and startups to have some money to actually work. When a new project or business starts, the founder has an idea to present. But that idea requires a lot of work to become into a product which takes time. I quote Henry Ford, "Time is Money". Founders spend time on the project but without anything to sell, they don't make any money. Crowd funders help by providing this money to the founders at the time they need it. Not everyone can spend money on crowd funding though. I believe, though, that it's not correct for companies with Multi million dollar profits to run crowd funding.

    • Dave P
      July 3, 2013 at 9:09 pm

      Thank you for commenting, Vishal. I generally agree, and I don't like seeing companies who already have lots of money at their disposal using crowdfunding sites. It stinks of taking advantage.