Should You Buy a Fitbit? 5 Honest Questions to Ask Before You Do

Ben Stegner Updated 10-12-2018

Fitbit devices exist to help you live a healthier life by tracking your fitness goals. After hearing success stories, it’s likely you’ve considered purchasing one for yourself. Maybe you’re trying to lose weight, training for an event, or just want to make healthier choices every day.


There’s no denying that Fitbit devices are interesting gadgets that may be an ideal workout companion for many individuals. But is a Fitbit worth it for you?

No matter which model you choose, you’re making an investment. Before you go out and buy one, ask yourself these simple Fitbit questions to know whether you should get a Fitbit and if it’s worth the money.

1. Do You Exercise Consistently?

This is the first question to ask yourself because it’s a trap that many people fall into. Simply put, a Fitbit is not a magic bullet that will suddenly give you the motivation to exercise.

Some people give every excuse imaginable for why they don’t work out. They claim that they can’t start until they have suitable clothes, or until the weather changes, or until they have the right gadget. But the truth is that it’s not these secondary aspects that prevent them from starting—it’s themselves.


If you don’t have the motivation to consistently work towards your exercise goals without a Fitbit, buying one is not going to suddenly change your ways. A fitness tracker is meant to track your habits and give you actionable data.

Know yourself and whether you’ll actually commit to a plan. Someone who won’t go for a walk today because they’re waiting for their Fitbit to arrive in the mail tomorrow will always find an excuse to avoid exercising.

In short: If you don’t exercise regularly and plan on a Fitbit alone motivating you to do so, don’t buy a Fitbit.

2. Will You Actually Wear It and Use It?

Man Wearing Fitness Tracker


Once you’re committed to exercising, you need to decide if you’ll actually wear your Fitbit regularly. If you dislike the feeling of wearing a watch or bracelet, you won’t like a Fitbit either.

For a fitness tracker to do its job, you have to wear it almost all the time. Failing to wear it during a walk or at night means it won’t record your steps and sleep accurately. And if you buy it only to have it sit in a drawer, what’s the point?

You can clip the smaller Fitbit Zip on your pocket, but this basic device can only tell you so much. Less-expensive devices like the Flex 2 simply snap in with a little connector, while the higher-end devices like the Charge 3 use a strap similar to a watch.

Those with sensitive skin could end up with irritations from wearing the Fitbit all the time. If your job prevents you from wearing a watch, you can’t wear your Fitbit during the day either.


No matter which Fitbit tracker you use, you’ll need the free app to access all the information it collects. Will you install those apps on your phone to keep up with your progress, or ignore them?

Fitness tracking tips and tricks won’t matter if you don’t regularly interact with your device and app.

In short: If you can’t commit to wearing the device almost all day, every day, don’t buy a Fitbit.

Download: Fitbit for Android | iOS | Windows 10 (Free)


3. Do You Enjoy Data?

The basics of losing weight and becoming healthier are simple, but the specifics for each human’s body can vary wildly.

Some people benefit from using the Fitbit device and app to record exactly how active they are and what they eat, keeping track of that data over time. Other people just try to eat fewer unhealthy foods, go for a jog every day, and don’t worry much about it.

If you’re in the latter camp, you might not care about everything a Fitbit offers. Most of the devices can tell you exactly how far you ran, how high your heart rate goes during a workout, and how active you’ve been during a day.

If you don’t care about any of those specifics and are happy with just getting some exercise in, a Fitbit might be a waste for you. On the other hand, if you need to keep an eye on certain statistics for a medical condition, having organized and detailed information at your fingertips can be a fantastic resource.

Those who thrive on information (like how many calories you’ve consumed and how far you’ve walked) will love what a Fitbit offers. But they’re a waste for someone who estimates those and doesn’t care to take the time to track them.

Also, now that Google owns Fitbit, you might wonder how safe your Fitbit data is with Google Google Buys Fitbit: What Does This Mean for Your Privacy? Google has bought Fitbit. What could a data tracking giant possibly want with a fitness tracking device? Read More . Especially considering that Google store medical data in the cloud Google Will Store Medical Data in the Cloud: Is That Good or Bad? Google now stores medical data in the cloud. But is this as safe, secure, and private as you want your medical history to be? Read More .

In short: If you don’t care exactly how many steps you’ve taken today or what your heart rate is, a Fitbit probably isn’t worth it for you.

4. Would a Lighter Alternative Do the Job?

Did you know that if you have a smartphone, you can try out a lot of what a Fitbit offers without paying?

You’ll find hundreds of fitness and pedometer apps 12 Free Pedometer Apps That Are Better Than Fitbit Want to track your steps without an expensive Fitbit? These Android and iPhone pedometer apps do the job just as well for free! Read More on both Android and iOS that can help with your health goals. Google Fit is Google’s solution on Android, while the Apple Health app is built into iOS. Fitbit’s mobile app can also perform some basic tracking even without a device connected.

Before you commit to buying a Fitbit, try using its app without a device. Or give either Google Fit or Apple Health a test run. Do this for two weeks.

Perhaps they do everything you’re interested in—great! Then you don’t need to spend money on a Fitbit. On the flip side, if you can’t commit to using one of these apps regularly for a few weeks, buying a new device won’t change that.

In short: If a free health-tracking app does everything you need, or if you can’t commit to using one consistently, you don’t need a Fitbit.

Download: Google Fit for Android (Free)

5. Do You Enjoy Competition?

There’s one key aspect of Fitbit we haven’t touched on yet: the social factor. The Fitbit app allows you to add friends and check how their step counts compare to yours. You can choose to post status updates to your friends letting them know that you’ve hit your goal for the day, or earned a milestone badge.

Beyond that, you can create groups and challenge your friends to specific challenges. For instance, Workweek Hustle challenges two to 10 people to get as many steps in as they can from Monday to Friday.

These are great features, but are they for you? If you don’t seek out friends that also use Fitbit, you won’t stay as accountable for your goals, which could sap your motivation. You don’t have to know other people who use Fitbit to enjoy having one, but you’re missing out on a whole sphere of the service if you don’t take advantage of this.

Taken to the extreme, though, the competition could become unhealthy if you obsess over it. So don’t take it too seriously.

In short: If you don’t have other friends who use Fitbit and can keep you accountable, you may want to avoid buying a Fitbit.

Which Fitbit Device Is Best for Me?

Fitbit offers several devices The Fitbit Comparison: Which Model Is Best for You? With so many Fitbit devices, it can be hard to choose one. Our Fitbit comparison will help you find the best Fitbit for you. Read More for different uses.

The most basic model, the Fitbit Zip, offers step and calorie tracking. On the other end of the spectrum, the Fitbit Ionic is a full-blown smartwatch and fitness tracker combination.

Several other models in between these, including the new Charge 3, fill different needs. We think that for most people, the Alta HR offers the best value for money.

A detailed comparison of each Fitbit model is beyond the scope of this article, but we’ve compared Fitbit devices to similar Garmin ones Fitbit vs. Garmin: Fitness Watches Compared In the market for a new fitness tracker? Then you've probably compared Fitbit vs. Garmin. We're here to help you decide which brand is best for you. Read More  to help you decide.

Decided to Buy a Fitbit?

We’ve covered five big questions that you should seriously ponder before investing in a Fitbit. A few other questions are worth considering as well, such as whether fitness trackers pose a security risk, if a Fitbit will match your fashion, and if you’re OK with remembering to charge another device regularly.

After thinking about these questions, if you decide to buy a Fitbit, congratulations! Hopefully, you enjoy it and it assists you in becoming healthier. With some additional services, you can create a complete automated health tracking setup Use Automated Health Tracking to Lose Weight and Live a Healthier Life Health tracking is about taking care of your food, your workouts, your productivity, and your moods. Modern fitness trackers can now automate it all to help you lose weight and live a healthier life Read More to get even more data about your body.

Image Credit: lev radin/Shutterstock

Related topics: Buying Tips, Fitbit, Fitness, Gadgets, Health.

Affiliate Disclosure: By buying the products we recommend, you help keep the site alive. Read more.

Whatsapp Pinterest

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Pushpa Desai
    May 9, 2020 at 1:04 am

    Very informative. Helped me decide if I should buy a Fitbit. Thanks.

  2. Teh Seng Huat
    April 25, 2020 at 12:39 am

    I have a Charge 3 and it is not reliable. Purchased in July 2018 and after wearing it less than 3 months the screen malfunction. Went to the shop they allow to replace but got to wait 3 to 5 months depending on stock availability. Got the replacement in February 2019. Just after the warranty 1 year period expired the screen now malfunction.

    Can I get replacement? Please advise. Thanks.

  3. Ned Newberry
    December 12, 2018 at 6:48 am

    I wear a fitness tracker for the heart rate reader. My doctor said something about irregular heart rate during the last checkup.

    Ideally I should wear an Apple watch since they seem to have a more robust system with regards to heart rate reading.

  4. Meredith
    April 15, 2018 at 6:00 pm

    That was a really well written and useful article. My workplace gave me a Fitbit and I've been pondering whether to start the process... I had to laugh reading these questions, they were so on target! It was question number 3 that really made me realize that I just have very little interest in this level of tracking and have no desire to add one more device to charge, keep track of, or follow. Thank you! I will happily pass it on to another employee.

  5. Stacey L
    January 17, 2018 at 11:19 pm

    The final question is: Do you want to be able to repair or replace your FitBit if you have an issue? You can only purchase from an authorized retailer and if it is over the 1 year warranty they will only give you a 25% discount on a new one. There are only a few- so make sure to check the list. I had mine- which I loved- for 1 year and 2 months. Now I am out $200. My advice- buy and Apple Watch or a Samsung! At least they can be repaired and replaced. Also- there is not a United States customer service section. You can only talk to reps over-seas.