4 Ways Online Reviews Are Being Manipulated By Manufacturers

Joshua Lockhart 01-08-2013

We all know that the Internet is full of advertisements How Money Is Made On YouTube [MakeUseOf Explains] Until a profitable, mutually beneficial alternative arrives, advertisements have to exist in order for us - the consumers - to receive content free of charge. YouTube isn't evil because it places advertisements at the beginning... Read More , but what some may not know is the fact that some advertisements pop up where you would least expect it. Where specifically? Online reviews.


Yep, manufacturers and companies actually manipulate reviews in a variety of ways right here on the Internet. It’s all about good press, of course. However, some ways are sketchier than others as you’ll soon be able to tell.

Some methods companies use are rather direct while others are a little more hands-off than others. Either way, you should know that it’s very important to investigate reviews while you are simultaneously investigating potential purchases.

Hiring SEO-Friendly PR

Public relations are a big part of any company, but in the modern age, you have to hire someone who knows what they are doing. For instance, most companies who are into the whole online review manipulation game hire such services which are heavy on search engine optimization Can SEO Companies Really Guarantee a Top 10 Google Result? SEO is one of the most misunderstood aspects of web design, it is also a primary target for scam artists that prey upon unsuspecting website owners, willing to do anything for a piece of the... Read More (SEO). As some of you may know, search engine optimization is a key element when it comes to online promotion, and it’s one part chance and one part science.


According the financial service Mint, companies have made use of such services as far back as 2010. In Internet time, that’s like a 30 years, so that’s a pretty good while. Public relation services tend to identify already-existing positive reviews and articles about their clients and use various optimization strategies to elevate them to the top of search engines. So while poor reviews exist, they typically fall to the bottom of the pile.


You really can’t blame these companies for wanting only their good sides to shine. Besides, everybody has bad press, and sometimes it’s overdone. Even still, if you want to find legitimate reviews, it would be in your best interest to look beyond the first few pages of search.

Posting Fake Reviews

In case you didn’t know, companies post fake reviews. (Real shocker, eh?) No, we all know about those fake reviews out there: “FANTASTIC SERVICE, WOULD COME AGAIN – GREAT PRODUCT!!!!!!!!” 

There’s not much of a way to claim this, but if you look around enough, you’ll find some copy-and-paste fantastic reviews here and there. Because of this, Cornell University created Review Skeptic, a site that is openly for “entertainment purposes only”.



The site came into existence after a study found that some hotels tend to publish glowing reviews about themselves all over the Internet. At Review Skeptic, you can copy and paste reviews on the site to verify if they are fake or not. Furthermore, if you know a review is fake, the site requests that you let them know — this helps save proper data for future usage.

Paying Off Consumers

Back in 2012, Time Magazine published an article about a company named VIP Deals which sold leather tablet cases for around $60. However, when potential buyers ran searches for the cases for their Amazon Kindles Hidden Kindle Features You Need To Know About Read More , an ad would pop up selling such cases for under $10 plus shipping and handling. In most circumstances, this would be considered sketchy. Guess what? It was sketchy.


Gullible customers took advantage of the offer, oddly enough, the cases did arrive, and as a matter of fact, they were legit – no cheap knockoffs. However, included in the packaging was a letter requesting the buyer to write a review on Amazon that also said, “We strive to earn 100 percent perfect ‘FIVE-STAR’ scores from you!”


Cool, cool. No problem here. There was a problem, though – this: “In return for writing the review, we will refund your order so you will have received the product for free.”

Yeah. Not cool. These things happen, folks.

Affiliate Reviews (We Don’t Do ‘Em, BTW)

Last but not least, there is the concept of affiliate linking. You may know about them, already. Consumers receive a custom link to a product from something like Amazon’s affiliate program, and whenever this link is clicked, they get paid a small amount. This is okay in some situations. For instance, if you were my friend, and you told me you were buying a product that I just bought, I could say, “Hey, do you mind using my affiliate link since I told you about the thing?”



Not too bad. What’s sketchy is when popular bloggers write amazing reviews about products, link to them, and then promote them on their website as if they are legitimate reviews. That? That’s a little wrong.

(As a note, at MakeUseOf, we’ve done a few sponsored reviews, but we make it clear that they are sponsored. We also don’t include affiliate links.)


Hopefully, the above notes will help you think about what you see about products you buy online. This isn’t necessarily an article that says, “BE PARANOID!” It’s more of an article that says, “Be thorough.” 

What other ways do manufacturers manipulate reviews? Do you have your own tips to spot fake reviews The Scourge Of The Web: Fake Reviews & How To Spot Them "User reviews" are actually a pretty recent phenomenon. Before the prevalence of the Internet, user reviews were called testimonials, and you’d only see them on TV commercials and product pages. Nowadays, anyone can write anything... Read More ? Have you ever based a purchase on a manipulated review and regretted it?

Image Credits: Back of executive Via Shutterstock

Affiliate Disclosure: By buying the products we recommend, you help keep the site alive. Read more.

Whatsapp Pinterest

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. John Woldermart
    December 30, 2015 at 3:31 pm

    It's not so easy to recognize fake reviews because there is no way of verifying them in most of the businesses. It's strange for me that there are no companies that are actually providing a proper way of authentication for the real customers. All the processes right now can be manevoured somehow. Only company I saw that's doing this is Honaro but I haven't tested it yet.

    I'm really wondering how is the problem going to be solved because it seems to be bigger and bigger and the companies are not trying to play fair.

  2. dragonmouth
    August 1, 2013 at 10:51 pm

    Companies manipulate reviews by withholding advertising from reviewers who pan them and awarding advertising to reviewers who praise them.

    Companies pay pollsters to produce favorable opinion polls.

  3. Dany B
    August 1, 2013 at 11:33 am

    Its not too hard to recognize fake review in customers review, usually these are the one that seem too articulate and polite. SO I usually discard thems as for professionnals review I know peoples get paid to write good or bad reviews, depending who pay for it, so I usually try to take only the informations from thoses review that don't seem biased, like general inormations about specs, etc...etc...

    • Joshua Lockhart
      August 7, 2013 at 8:11 am

      As someone who occasionally writes articulate and polite reviews for products that I buy, you now have me concerned. : )