What Do You Really Think Of Windows 8? [You Told Us]

Ads by Google

The release of Windows 8 is, at the time of writing, a mere three months away. The time to make sweeping changes has passed, and Microsoft will be unleashing a version of Windows 8 very close to the preview versions we’ve tried and tested (and in some cases dismissed out of hand) here at MakeUseOf.

Microsoft has taken a huge gamble in its strategy for remaining in the game against Apple and Google in the emerging post-PC era, delivering an operating system designed to work on every device out there. This one-size-fits-all approach sounds nice on paper, but in reality it can lead to dissatisfaction and disillusionment. Leading us to last week’s ‘We Ask You‘ all about Windows 8.

What Do You Really Think Of Windows 8?

We asked you, What Do You Really Think Of Windows 8? The response was fantastic, with dozens of people weighing in with their thoughts about the forthcoming operating system. The discussion was wide-ranging and interesting, so be sure to click the link above to read the thread in its entirety. There were a couple of trends amongst the comments though.

The range of opinions was vast. Bob Henson hates Windows 8, concluding his comment with, “Final conclusion – sell your Microsoft shares now!” While Jon Butler loves Windows 8, calling it “by far the fastest, leanest version of Windows to date.” Most people were somewhere in the middle, liking aspects of Windows 8 while wondering whether it will succeed or fail.

Many people wish Microsoft had opted to release two different and distinct flavors of Windows 8; one for touchscreen devices and the other for keyboard-and-mouse computers. Trying to marry the two into one operating system is being seen as a gamble that could backfire by pleasing no one in particular. Even the option to permanently switch off the Metro UI would be enough of a compromise for most people.

Comment Of The Week

Comment of the week goes to Ben, who, as well as the respect of myself and hopefully everybody reading this, receives 150 MakeUseOf points to use for Rewards or Giveaways (or at least he will if he sets up a MakeUseOf user account within the next week).

Ads by Google

Back in the early 90s, the majority of software people used was DOS based and so most people spent the majority of their time at the command line, and would start Windows (by typing WIN) and use it when/if necessary. It wasn’t until Windows 95, that things had changed such that people spend the majority of their time in Windows, and so Microsoft made it so Windows 95 booted straight away bypassing the command prompt.

The experience of running a DOS-based app under Windows at the time was just as “jarring” as running a desktop (non-Metro) app under Windows 8 is now. But just as before, as time goes on and more Metro software is written, and more touch-based hardware comes to market, it wont be an issue because people will naturally start to spend more time in the Metro environment (and it is pretty good!).

The issue for me right now, is the fact that you’re forced into the Metro environment when the reality is that 99.9% of the work I need to do, and probably will for the near future, requires the Windows desktop.
I just wish that I could choose which environment I see by default, desktop or Metro. Microsoft’s biggest mistake IMHO is that they’re forcing people to use Metro and I really think that such a dramatic shift, requires a much more gradual transition.

This is a great comment that ties Microsoft’s past with its present and future. People invariably don’t like change, and it often needs to be forced on them rather than merely offered as an option. The point made here is that Microsoft could have eased us into the Metro UI with Windows 8 so that we’d all be more willing to make the move at a later date. Windows 9 perhaps.

We will be asking a new question tomorrow, so please join us then. ‘We Ask You’ is a weekly column dedicated to finding out the opinions of MakeUseOf readers. We ask you a question and you tell us what you think. The question is open-ended and is usually open to debate. Some questions will be purely opinion-based, while others will see you sharing tips and advice, or advocating tools and apps for your fellow MakeUseOf readers. This column is nothing without your input, all of which is valued.

Join live MakeUseOf Groups on Grouvi App Join live Groups on Grouvi
Windows Troubleshooting
Windows Troubleshooting
28 Members
Windows_10
Windows_10
34 Members
Windows Hacks & Customization
Windows Hacks & Customization
46 Members
Best Windows Software
Best Windows Software
28 Members
Ads by Google
Comments (28)
  • Kenice Noel

    I’ve tried every public preview version of Windows 8 and I am lucky to have the final version as a DreamSpark premium user. Windows 8 is a radical shift away from Windows past, but it’s daring and as a tech junkie I welcome the change.
    For folks who use the computer for general purposes, it WILL take a little getting used to (and require digging deeper in to the os to get some simple tasks done) but in the end, I like where Microsoft is going with Windows 8 and their other services.

  • suks

    I tried the RT version of windows 8 and it looked astonishing. Although the RT version lacked some features and certain others were disabled, but when everything is out there working. IT IS GOING TO ROCK THE WORLD!!!

  • Wojtek Swiatek

    “People invariably don’t like change”

    This is not a rule, particularly for geeks. I was glad to move from NT to 2000, then to XP and then to Win7 – very much positive changes to me.

    Metro (or the newUI or whatever it is called now) is different in the sense that it does not help me to work better on a desktop. Maybe on a tablet (I do not own a Win tablet). This itself should have led MS to either keep the Win7 desktop version or make Metro more useable on a desktop.
    Otherwise it will be a fail for desktop users, and particularly enterprise desktop users.

  • Timothy Liem

    IMHO, the tile UI sucks. so disgusting and annoying to see your desktop filled with huge boxes that move on their own. I personally will stick with 7 as it’s best windows release so far. look how beautiful Aero is (although it definitely is a copy of KDE). much more stable than trashy Vista and keep a low requirement as XP (well, a bit more of course). but still, I dislike Windows because of its security issues, freezing overtime, fragmentations, and so on. so I will switch to Ubuntu soon while I keep 7 only for gaming.

  • Charlie Player

    not that bad.. i tried it

Load 10 more
Affiliate Disclamer

This review may contain affiliate links, which pays us a small compensation if you do decide to make a purchase based on our recommendation. Our judgement is in no way biased, and our recommendations are always based on the merits of the items.

For more details, please read our disclosure.
Affiliate Disclamer

This review may contain affiliate links, which pays us a small compensation if you do decide to make a purchase based on our recommendation. Our judgement is in no way biased, and our recommendations are always based on the merits of the items.

For more details, please read our disclosure.