Pinterest Stumbleupon Whatsapp
Ads by Google

A recent story from The Washington Post gave the public a rare inside view of the social media monitoring capabilities of the Fresno police department, which is trialling a controversial piece of software called Beware. The piece has caused quite a stir over the software’s supposed proclivity for civil liberties violations.

But how is this program different from other social media monitoring done by the police? Is Beware an actual civil liberties threat? Or is this whole thing being overblown? And what can you do to keep the police from digging through your social media posts?

An Obvious Tool for Police Departments

Law enforcement officers have likely been using social media for intelligence gathering since it became mainstream – even back in 2006, police arrested an underage boy in Colorado after he posted pictures of himself on MySpace with a number of firearms.

Social media’s use in investigations has only become more commonplace since then, and there are a number of stories testifying to its efficacy. In 2014, New York police seized over 250 illegally sold guns after an extensive investigation that started when officers noticed an aspiring rapper had posted images of guns in his studio on Instagram.

social-media-gun-bust

There have been countless reports of students being arrested for posting bomb and other threats against their schools, and many arrests after posts that advocate violence against police. Even joke bomb threats How To Use Twitter Without Screwing Up How To Use Twitter Without Screwing Up Twitter can be a touch cryptic, and it's easy to make mistakes from time to time – even if you're a longtime user. Here are a few common mistakes, and how to avoid them. Read More have resulted in arrests. This isn’t limited to the US, either; there’s ample precedent in the UK for being arrested based upon saying something “grossly offensive” or threatening on social media.

Ads by Google

Social media has become an important locale for gang posturing and threats, and police in cities like Chicago and New York have made a surprising number of arrests based on Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram posts in which gang members are either doing something illegal or expressing their intent to do so.

All in all, social media monitoring is an obvious choice for law enforcement – if people are posting their illegal exploits on Facebook, where the entire world can see them, it’s going to pay off to monitor it.

The Issue with Beware: An Algorithmic Approach

So if police have been monitoring social media for years, why is Fresno’s approach making headlines? Part of the answer lies in the fact that Beware uses an algorithmic approach to monitoring social media. Many simplistic social media monitoring tools (even those used by social media marketers Your Guide To Social Media Marketing Your Guide To Social Media Marketing Right now, there is an onslaught of both people and companies turning to social media outlets. The competition is fierce, and no company can waste time or money doing it wrong. Read More ) just look for specific keywords or patterns in the data, something that individual police officers do on a much smaller scale.

But Beware, when given an individual’s information, calculates a “threat score” based on, according to Intrado’s website,

…billions of [publicly]-available commercial records in a matter of seconds—alerting responders to potentially dangerous situations while en route to, or at the location of, a 9-1-1 request for assistance.

The billions of points of data come from social media posts, arrest and other public records, commercial databases, and many other types of data, though exactly where they come from and how they’re translated into a green, yellow, or red threat score is a trade secret guarded by Intrado, the maker of the software.

beware-insight

How the police use this scoring system, however, is obvious – if a 911 caller or someone involved in the call has a yellow or red threat score, officers will be more wary going in. Which could very well mean being more highly armed and ready for trouble, a mindset that could have serious consequences for the caller.

In 2007, police were investigating the theft of two PlayStation consoles on a college campus when they discovered pictures of the suspect posing with a number of firearms on social media. They sent a SWAT team to the suspect’s house, and another student ended up dead after an officer mistook the sounds of the battering ram used to gain entrance to the house for gunshots. This is exactly the sort of heavily armed response based on information gleaned from social media that has people worried.

The Post‘s story mentioned that a woman who tweeted about the game Rage and a man who lived in a house previously occupied by a person of interest both had elevated threat levels. Neither of these people would have been given a second thought by a flesh-and-blood officer, but Intrado’s software could put officers on edge if they were to respond to a call from either of these citizens.

police-gear

What’s worrying to many people is that threat score calculations are being made by an algorithm developed by a single company that’s not going to share its equations anytime soon – Beware is a total black box. Algorithms already control significant portions of our lives 4 Machine Learning Algorithms That Shape Your Life 4 Machine Learning Algorithms That Shape Your Life You may not realize it but machine learning is already all around you, and it can exert a surprising degree of influence over your life. Don't believe me? You might be surprised. Read More , but the fact that they may now put us in a dangerous situation is starting to get people’s attention.

Algorithmic approaches to policing have drawn a large amount of criticism in the past, with some critics saying that they’re prone to racial profiling, and others going on to say that the tools are flat-out “racist.” Research on the topic is inconclusive, with some studies showing a decrease in short-term crime and other showing no significant effect of the predictive technology.

A Legacy of Surveillance

The analysis of “billions” of data points brings to mind some previous programs undertaken by the US government.

iao-logo

Total Information Awareness (TIA) was an initiative undertaken by the Information Awareness Office in the early 2000s that collected information on credit card purchases, magazine subscriptions, web browsing, e-mail, academic grades, travel, legal events, and other types of information for storage in a central database. Even after being rebranded as Terrorist Information Awareness, TIA was shut down due to public outrage over the frankly Orwellian idea.

One of DARPA’s research projects You Won't Believe It: DARPA Future Research Into Advanced Computers You Won't Believe It: DARPA Future Research Into Advanced Computers DARPA is one of the most fascinating and secretive parts of the US government. The following are some of DARPA's most advanced projects that promise to transform the world of technology. Read More looked into a similar system called LifeLog that would collect…

…every activity and relationship a person engages in. This is to include credit card purchases, web sites visited, the content of telephone calls and e-mails sent and received, scans of faxes and postal mail sent and received, instant messages sent and received, books and magazines read, television and radio selections, physical location recorded via wearable GPS sensors, [and] biomedical data captured through wearable sensors.

Obviously, Beware and other social media monitoring solutions aren’t nearly this advanced, and don’t have quite the same potential for privacy violations. However, the US government’s pattern of creating privacy-violating pieces of software that either aren’t well understood by the public or are kept under wraps has a lot of people nervous. And social media monitoring by the police is looking like it could become a civil liberties battleground.

Many people have already taken sides. The large number of social-media-monitoring programs available indicate that many police departments and other organizations (including schools) are interested in using this technology.

aclu-headline

On the other hand, groups like the ACLU have already spoken out against the tech, saying that it could allow police departments to “place people under suspicion simply for speaking their mind online.” The ACLU’s blog post on the topic was provocatively titled “This Surveillance Software is Probably Spying on #BlackLivesMatter Hashtag Activism: #powerful or #pointless? Hashtag Activism: #powerful or #pointless? #BringBackOurGirls, #ICantBreathe, and #BlackLivesMatter have seen wide international coverage in the past year – but are hashtags an effective means of activism? Read More ,” though there’s little evidence that this is the case.

And, of course, all of the information pulled in by Beware is “commercially available.” Exactly what that means is difficult for anyone to know, as the types of data that social networks sell seem to change all the time. As we’ve seen in the past, it’s not hard to get information that a user thinks is private Prepare Your Account Privacy For Facebook Graph Search [Weekly Facebook Tips] Prepare Your Account Privacy For Facebook Graph Search [Weekly Facebook Tips] Every time Facebook releases a new feature to learn more about our friends, many people realise that their privacy settings are not adequate anymore. Their latest new feature, Facebook Graph Search, is no exception -... Read More just by asking the right questions and using the right tools.

I wouldn’t be the first person to associate Beware and other social media monitoring solutions with Minority Report‘s pre-crime or 1984‘s thought crime.

1984-cover

The sophistication of software like Beware is getting to the point where it can likely draw conclusions based on the things you don’t say, but only imply. Intrado and other manufacturers don’t want their software linked to dystopian science-fiction novels, but the connection is obvious.

Lessons Learned

Whether you’re worried about the potential privacy violations caused by social media monitoring software in the hands of law enforcement or not, this should serve as a reminder that whatever you put out on Facebook or Twitter isn’t just available to your friends. It’s out there forever, and it’s likely in the hands of a wide variety of people and companies.

The best thing you can do is to not post stupid things on social media. Don’t make jokes about doing something illegal. Don’t advocate violence against police or members of the military. Don’t post pictures of yourself that could be construed as threatening (especially with guns—just don’t post pictures of yourself with guns). A lot of this is common sense, but Fresno and their use of Beware should underline the importance of these sorts of protective measures.

social-network-mapping

This is also an important issue to keep in mind in the face of the upcoming US presidential election 6 Resources to Help You Track the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election 6 Resources to Help You Track the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election The people’s right to vote determines the outcome of an election. Be an informed voter and take this important task seriously with the help of these tools. Read More  (where social media is also an extremely important tool Political Campaigns Are Tracking You on Facebook, Here's Why Political Campaigns Are Tracking You on Facebook, Here's Why You know by now that companies and government use social media to track you. But there's another group that's watching, analyzing, and capitalizing on every move you make on Facebook: political campaigners. Read More , interestingly). This issue could very well come to a head shortly after a new president is sworn in, and how it plays out from there may depend on who’s sitting in Oval Office. It may seem like a minor issue now, but this could be a very big deal in the near future. It’s worth keeping an eye on.

What do you think about police departments monitoring social media? Do you feel that they’re justified in using an algorithmic approach? Or do you think it’s likely to lead to racial profiling and inaccurate judgments? Should we be worried about the progression of this kind of software?

This is a complicated issue, and I’m not even totally sure how I feel about it. It leaves too much in the hands of an algorithm that surveils people without their knowledge. But it could also help save the lives of officers headed into dangerous situations. Help me hash it out in the comments below.

Image Credits: Scott Cornell via Shutterstock.com, Ivelin Radkov via Shutterstock.com.

  1. ab
    April 28, 2016 at 11:50 am

    satan game in Iraq . Between nightmare. And fact. My greetings I am not professional writer .but I just reflect the real scandal in Iraq to all . Hoping first to warn others .and know who lead this country ..also warn to who visit this country from responsible ..or presidents of others countries . Cause the go not to respcable country respect the guest but group of Satan only .I advise any one visit Iraq from responsible to stay in any place that the brothers in coalition troops in .This for his safety . Yes cause all who rule now .those just masks only .next you will know who rule Iraq from behind the darkness . .and those not human but those hate Iraq and democracy .and life .child minds .only ..putting key of Iraq in their bucket .so strange way to. To rule my be all know that impossible to some one put a key of country in his hand .how did country like car or box unclock it by key and open . How some thing so strange .but in Iraq it became . Now what the key of Iraq . This satanic kingdom .biggest spy net connect directly with satellite .This satellite deal with so complicated program .and codes .Some one have computer .This alone can deal with satellite . The net .of satan .it's big gangs . .no one can give it's order just by satellite .only . .electronic airplanes .Every one have orders .also mind control gangs . .This satanic net call it self as organisation to hide it self . But it's not . .its so danger gangs no like . Whom 2* lead it's hide them self . And use silly ways .to cheat the foolish people's . By for example putting spy tool on some one .And by this they can lead their gangs . Some thing so hard to believe it's . How some one have members . Belong to him .And same time he lead them by some one else he just use his body only . .its kind of big trick . By the way the one who they use body can't give any order to any one of gangs .cause he just like donkey carry spy tool only . . Satan hide him self and lead his cattle of gangs . By using his body .This ways of evil .to lead .After period he kill this who carry the spy tool and put another one . ..now let me tell about what kind of articles satan fabricated to his gangs . It's like inside gangs laws .This laws no one work on its just satan gangs only .its like how u can this work in this gangs or not .As I said satan use bodies of others in his ways to hide himself . When he hunted .Some one ..He putted his spy tool on him ..now look at his evil way .He made the victim as leader but facts he like donkey only . Who decide or give order satan only . Satan will made him self as Secretary to him .or servant to him .as I said . The victom putted on him spy tool . Only .. now satan have computer . He see what victom see and hear . Beside read his thoughts . This victom when he eat or drink or take some thing or talk or take money or thing ..or stay in place . Satan come and cheated any one the 3* from whom his victom talked or took money or thing else from them .. and recorded them on his dark record .or his computer and start give them laws of gangs .and order of steal and damage ..and cheated them that who gave this order not him but his victom .cause he lie on them saying this victom their manager and he just secretary to him only .. now more joke and fun .His victom.some one so poor didn't have any money .And he didn't know any thing and he have tongue like others and know that if some one have members follow him .They must obey his tongue ..now focus on Satan ways . And how he play .as I said he use his victom to lead his castles only .how by spy tool on him.. and one of his lies to his castles to not believe the tongue of his victom .For example if he said I am poor .or didn't have any members follow him .else .He say don't belive cause he lie .He give me order only this is the rule and me give u .you take orders from me .only and this orders from him to me .and me give it's for you ..and his cattle obey him . What evil way to hide . Also he fabricated another cheat .like order by eat for example when his victom eat he give order and if his victom take money or use things or talk or think. .He by spy see and hear .This and he give his orders to his castles ..of course orders he want it's just .as I said no tongue to his victom . What ever he said .. This evil ways to lead his castles I mean the gangs . .now if one of 4* know about this trick that he been used from Satan by spy tool . putted on his body .and Satan lead his gangs by his body .what he will do .of course if he believe that he lead even one of this catttles he will be foolish number one. How cause those take money .from Satan.and he didn't have any money to give any one of them .and he is so poor ..This so clear .also those didn't obey him and his tongue .those salves of Satan only and he is just body been used to few time time as Satan want then throw him .die ... .For example when he try to use thiem .to revenge to him self from Satan .also he will be big foolish .cause he is their master not him..and he alone who give orders not him he just body only .used only no else . Now let me tell you about Satan plan .and how he lead his castles . He divided those to two group every group sperated on the others but just with him and his close follower .that is some one so evil he have mind control .and he work in police . He also have authority on both group of Satan castles . Both as I said recorded in same Satan computer . Took money and laws and orders .from Satan and his close evil ..now one of this group did evil things so clear . .and he made the other quiet ..This quiet like snake hidden . He used as trick .to coalition troops and their friends .to fallen in it. Cause it's be a quiet .but it's like another's face of coien . Only . The others hand of evil only . To play by it 6* this group have as I said many aims to made its quiet not like others hand of evil ..One its trick . Also it's give to the group one kind of legal .how as I said no legal to any articles of Satan laws in his net .I mean .eat .drink .know hide things ..take money or things .talk ..or use read thought .or kill who fired from this gangs .also from his gangs laws ...This second group used to give all this silly articles kind of legal ..other aim .He give some how authority to this group to implement laws in side . I mean when group one or his close one the evil who use mind control .kill people by mind control . .This second group .as the lie it's must punish him .And this big fun .cause this Satan refuse any punishment .just from this second group . Why cause this mean exactly one hand steal and know one can punish it just the other hand . Yes friends this what happened . Of course no any punish just laugh on minds only . . Cause any hurt mean it's hurt itself also ..This net of evil . Killed the brothers in coalition troops ..whom liberated Iraq . Also it's against brothers in France .and in bilguim . Recently . .I told Un about its .a lot . And asking remove their satellite .cause not legal to this gangs to use this technology .cause it's gangs only . But unfortunately no any action against this . Spider wizard net ... its still in Iraq play it's games . And killing Iraq people's by mind control 7* iraqi es people's fallen by secret die causes . And mind control behind it's ..but to whom I say this .to the second hand of evil that made itself represent laws and refuse any one punish just it .to find my self on dangerous only .and who I accused he will took reward . As punish . Yes friends .cause as I said .who lead this second group Satan of course and it's from his net . And this net Satan the manger and his right hand the evil who use mind control and this net contain from two group . Now so clear . That both group just castles only ..how can one of them stop or punish who kill people's by mind control . .who pinsh who .. He punish any group of them cause he is deputy or Satan assentence.the right hand of him. . And Satan lead all .. .This Satan net in Iraq ..by some way .They took not fair authority . They didn't deserve . 8* but it still no change on its . And in real it's source of danger . It's like neauclear weapons between hands of evil .He can hurt any one he want . . He want all kiss his feet . And do any thing he want ..deleted any any laws . And as useual foolish servant inside his box or computer . .He use . Those take orders . . My friends this matter must we take care about its .who own this computer .use it for evil only .and servant became soldiers of evil and his son . Evil and his son didn't care about those servant at all . And they throw thiem by any thing evil . Cause they have their remote control the computer .those foolish servant didn't obey any one or take advise from him .When he say to thiem evil lead u . .or try to refer to thiem good way instead of evil ways that they in . No any care .Their closing top closed .just code of this computer lead it's . My friends this not joke at all but real .facts . . again let me repeat the system of this computer . As I said there is a person must putted on him tool of spy and mind control chips . And there computer who own this Satan and his son .now look what happened .The person or victom .think about some one .His name inside the computer or take things any kind of thing .or talk or take money . Else . Now what happen. This became with Satan computer .and from this computer to satellite .I mean by this not from the victom to satellite but 9* but reference come from victom to the computer of Satan and from this computer to satellite .The orders from satellite to foolish servant . To electronic airplanes .I am sure the orders to hurt France and belugim came by this way .cause those servant do any thing any thing . Even hurt brother to thiem by order .This so danger .cause those servant have member in France sure .. and those given order .To hurt France .. With out any mind thing .. also in Belgium .. The Sanger my friends from those foolish servant only cause they are the hands of this net . .my be my friends some one of you have experience more than me .about this . I gave suggest to remove the satellite entirely . By this all servant will end .. One of my thinking I give it 10 precent that this net in past some one good have it and all those servant to do good only not evil .but Satan and his son .killed who own it and take this computer and begain to use it for evil . Using from one important thing that those servant didn't obey any one just from computer .whatever some one try . I say this cause I try a lot to convince a lot that all the laws that they work not legal and all its big break to human rights . No one bleng to good organisation when they fired him they kill him .no any organisation like this . Just gangs do this .beside the tongue of human .how you obey some with out take his talk .who tell .that he want this .even when he 10* when he think .my be he will change .and how he can think and mind control chip on his mind .press on him . So dangerous those foolish servant .but servant to who. My friends .not for the victom who think or take thing or money .or talk . But to who own the computer . That have a lot of spy tool .. He can putt one on donkey .and those servant the same .behave .. cause those didn't take tongue . .now we know that orders come from who own computer and his son .who use mind control . Only . And the victom nothing . Whatever he said .He is nothing .no one care . Now also the servant whom have electronic airplanes . Those castles .whom obey who own the computer only let say few joke . To show this foolishness to this servant . For example the victom go and stay in place whom live in love Brazil . For example . The servant will start help Brazil .but when he go and stay in place hate Brazil those foolish servant will start to hurt Brazil . .This mean the same servent whom help they became hurt .. those servent didn't care about what the victom say .He love Brazil even when he stay between people's hate Brazil .but those foolish servent didn't take any talk from him .. .just who own computer . .Satan and his son .. now complete Satan and his son .what they do for example this victom stay in some place .They go to thiem and give thiem money to became so hate to Brazil .and talked against its .now foolish servent will be so ha 11* so hated to Brazil .and do any thing and hope from those who hate Brazil to hurt Brazil and of course this hope not from thiem but Satan and his son. Only . . Satan who own this computer now .He is entelgent officer and his son who use mind control he is in police . .but those have this secret magic wizard crystal ball . .by this ..The son of evil .announce that he have Iraq .He have people's and government .I think he mean this computer .that he and Satan own .It. and in it servent with minds of cows .. .how can some deal .With this net . Still watch and wait .what Satan and his son .plan and what kind of evil order they give . Focus on Iraq .They hurt France ..also think they will not do it again . They did with Belgium . .In Iraq those play as they want . Made this hurt this .As they want . Made problem .and when it end .They did another's ..use this against this . By remote control . They didn't need any reason to play this game ..who can read the thoughts of Satan and who use mind control to know what they plan ..about me I did out of my capacity my friends . I am just one .only . Just one .No one with me .At all . No money so poor no gun ..no organisation with me at all .No chief of my trib .not in government or police or security . .not political . Not chief on my family and thief wife son . No in englic church . This mean I am nothing .at all . This gangs spy on me 24 hour .and play on my head . Those 13*to know it just the group number two in Satan net .its in his dark magic computer . He lead it and his son who work in police .not me .and any identity to it .but it's lie .that it's different ..but this just cheat . .only . It's in same net .same record same laws of evil same son of Satan can lead it and ride on their back like donkey whatever he want . And give it any direction he want .same money .. It have ..and it didn't even look at me as some thing .And my word nothing to its . It's Ring In Satan Finger Only .He Order It To Say I am Manger To It. And it obey .This trick a lot fallen in especially from friends of coalition troops .. . My friends no one can deal with any of those cattle cause they are in side Satan computer .and this so danger .I announced that I am alone no organisation to Me no one with me .to made this as warn to all the friends to not be cheated by any organisation .to me or some one cheat thiem and say he with me . And give thiem orders saying I give . Nothing I am now so danger on my brother USA and coalition troops .why .cause those spy on me .and those killers and gangs . Did I became crazy to made my brothers and their friends in big danger . Of course not . . But this satanic net try to cheat . And give me wrong picture fake picture only .its my bad luck also made this cloud of enemy of my brothers on my head . Lie on others saying follow me .Yes my friends those animals lies on this . 14* those didn't obey any words from me .those not me who lead . All leaded by Satan and his son .only . No one in this net I have re looking relation with .. and all their satanic laws I didn't confess . And every thing they did .They only responsible on it . I didn't have any relation with entelegent or police Satan and his son . My be use the foolish servant for entelegent and security but secure who .not secure Iraq or any thing good .but secure the evil only .. secure the drugs .and child sex . And slavery .and secure to those whom killed people's by mind control . Yes this net and foolish servant . Did this . I don't know did Vatican know about this net in Iraq or not . Cause those lie and said the holy spirt told thiem and know hide thing . . Those not represent Christian at all .. now my friends put your minds on this danger matter .cause those evil tried to paralysed my brain by mind control to prevent thinking .. to find good more suggestions . Now you know . A big net have two group .Both in computer . Who have this Satan and his son . Those both group have biggest money .those blind servant .They obey who own .The computer .only . This computer connect with satellite .. its like the famous story of alah all deen . And magic box . And big guein . Who can do any thing to who own this box didn't care about who own it .Also didn't care . For example they ask him to built bridge here after few another take the same 15* the same box and ask him to damage this bridge that he built and build bridge in another place .He do .And after few. Those in past own this box again and repeat damage this and built here .yes friends .This is the truth .cause those servant no mind to thiem at all .by the way .I lose my mind fewly when I thought I can talk with thiem . And made thiem like human .and put thiem out of this he'll computer that Satan and his son .own . And try to made a group like a friends to my brothers and let thiem get out out this . I failed . .those no mind at all . No any identity to thiem . No mind .The head full empty . From any brain . .those just like machine only the talk with thiem .just lose time only . Some one you see him in bad you advice him .He refuse and still in his badness . .I told thiem that this laws will send you to he'll ..I have good way for you .Best thousands once from your now situation .you will be so good . He refuse .and laugh on my mind . Cause he is just machine only no mind on his head . Foolish and happy in his foolishness . Bleive me friends .. those like this and more worst . ..In any way .They will not be some thing to me .cause u don't have organisation .at all ..and they them self know that Satan and his son lead thiem and gave thiem silly laws . And their record .and money and the son of Satan authority . They know they are not m y organisation .and me not chief on thiem . .but Satan and his 16* those nlp and their electronic airplanes and their lies . No my organisation .those made thieself as government .In every place I be .In .those play on minds of others .mind control government .leading by Satan and his son .. .you see my friends no me who lead any thing ..Both group I don't have any relation with thiem ..This satanic net in Iraq .. not my organisation .. at all .and I am just normal person in Iraq didn't lead any thing .no government .no member or follow er . I didn't represent any one just my self only . I have tongue . For example when I wanted to write to you I use frankly way.to made you know this facts .I didn't say my greetings . Just and I became eat some thing or drink tea or use some thing. Refer to you .For example you are from canda I didn't use Canadian poetry .to made you know all what I said . Or think else from their silly ways .I use frankly way to made you know all this truth about this satanic net .In Iraq .those hide in Iraq some thing so difficult . Cause those have their members and use their spy net .and electronic airplanes . No real laws come near thiem . As I said as they putted condition that no one punish thiem just one from their net .and this biggest mistake .how cause this net have both group . Both leaded by Satan and his son .to whom I can say .to some one in second group . What he will do.his manger and his debuty . I talk against .did he can do some thing against .impossible . .beside why when I inform 17* against this gangs .I found one like thiem put his noise in what I said yet now I can't understand who tell him .I talked against some one use trick of know hide things .eat drink .take money .things .talk .else .All this he also work in .cause he from Satan net .who ask him some thing ..those unfortunately .use this way to flee .and one protect other. I know both group just cattle of cows .I know who lead it Satan and his son . Both group .He lead .I talked against Satan and his son .. .but both group can't do any thing cause those whom lead it .For example mind control both group can't do any thing against why .so easy cause he is debuty assentanc of who lead it's .He have authority on thiem .its like you inform soldier against his directly officer ..did any one expect some thing the soldier will do .This soldier my be can punish soldier less from him or equal .but his direct officer impossible ..those both group like this .Both Satan and who work in police .those as leaders .to both group .any one from those groups .can't do any thing .And no any useful ...I try .those a lot ..may be Satan .made thiem didn't know he is their manger .and his son . . .those can't do any thing to stop killing operation by mind control .cause who did this .thier manger .Satan give him full authority to lead his cows .I mean both groups .. those with electronic airplanes just cows only blindly obey . To Satan and his son .The only way .didn't be cheat by those 18* the only way to deal with those .no trust .no trust by any one give me any kind of picture . For example .I said to you I don't have organisation .I am poor .not have any one follow me .Not chief of my trib .not in elnglic church .not in government .not in police or entelgent . Not in political . Not chief on my family and their wife son .represent my self ..didn't lead any thing .Not in past or now . .any one give another picture he is lier .no true to him .. cause those use lies . Only .I am not in this net .never .and I didn't choice for thiem .so funny choice what .choice cow from cows of Satan and his son .. choice cow .look at me like what Satan and his son order it. I know all cows in this net .just cows .didn't have even itself . Even the relation of friends with thiem not found .my be I say this as talk .but friend in same meaning .truly .no one .cause all just cows .didn't belive by my tongue when I said I don't have organisation . I am nothing .In Iraq .. This satanic net not my organisation . Also I didn't in government or political or elnglic church or police or chief on my trib else from real facts . No one with me .I am not responsible about whom spy on me .and talk lies . I have tongue .. only . . In real this gangs play ugly game in Iraq . This satanic net rule Iraq from darkness ..and what shameful facts .This is . But I am not responsible about this at all .I didn't give those any thing to so simple reason .I didn't have 19* any thing to give .For example .did some one can give apples to others if he didn't apples ..how .of course not .how can I give position in government or security .or police if I myself didn't have any position . .did any one have just little mind can bielve this lie .I didn't give any thing cause I don't have any thing .to give no money .no position . I am not responsible at all .to whom spy on me and give money or position . Using .my relation of when I talk or eat or my friends .or take things or money or think . . Even if I said for example to some one I put u on security did this will be legal .impossible .cause I didn't have any high position to do this . Why I didn't put myself more best .from putting some one else .first .Then I put others . But if I didn't have .I can't give .its real .. I am good I wish good for all .and if I have good things all time I give from its .but if I didn't have of course I can't give . . Especially those cows of Satan .even if I have some thing those I will not .give them any thing. .I dint have any thing can some one use or steal ..and the game of Satan and his son .just game .by sticking one . One of their cattle on me and order it to say it's with me .or belong to Me .and still hurt it or steal .It .all this just games cause it's not belong to me at all ..its just trick from those .only .. I tried it . A lot .Over one year . And cover this big game .This cattle just second group of Satan and
    You can so easy make sure about what I said about this satanic kingdom .by asking the nato alliance to observe this place in Iraq by satellite .The place Iraq in diwanyah city in afak town .yes friends .This place . By you this you will not need me or contact by me or any one else . You will cover this cloud of evil and how it spy on me and follow me in any place I been . And throw it's net like spider .on the place that I been .and be gain it's game . To cheated others . And divided them two group

  2. brian
    March 17, 2016 at 8:01 am

    Its a simple violation and they dont care .. i bet 90% of people are marked.

    • Dann Albright
      March 22, 2016 at 7:28 pm

      You think it's that many? What do you think drives the marking of that many people?

  3. fcd76218
    February 15, 2016 at 5:49 pm

    It has been shown time and time again that data can be sliced and diced to make anyone seem like a criminal. The successes of social media monitoring software is loudly trumpeted to the world (seizure of 254 guns in NYC). What about the failures when police, because of Beware's profiling, shoot first and ask questions later?

    Going back to the late 1800s, criminologists and police agencies have been trying to come up with algorithms that predict people's criminal behavior. Using phrenology comes to mind as one of the methods. Most of the algorithms worked in test environments where the data input was controlled. However, out in the wild, they all proved unreliable by providing way too many false positives.

    • Dann Albright
      February 22, 2016 at 12:11 am

      It will certainly be interesting to see how it affects the behavior of the police—I don't think we'll really know until it gets more widespread. Which is a little concerning. I don't know about comparing it to phrenology, but it'll certainly be interesting to see what happens!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *