The Moblin Netbook OS – Giving Chrome OS A Run For Its Money

moblin logoGoogle’s new netbook-oriented operating system, Chrome OS, got more than its fair share of press when its source code was released (including a download from our very own Jorge Sierra.) But Google’s not the only major tech company developing a speedy, open-source operating system for netbooks – Intel’s been working on Moblin netbook OS since 2007.

The project’s now operated by the Linux Foundation, but Intel programmers still contribute a fair amount of code and serve on the project’s board.

Moblin netbook OS is meant to be a lot of things: user-friendly, Internet-oriented and based on existing standards, just to name a few. But Moblin’s most significant strength is supposed to be how well it runs on Intel’s Atom processor.

I loaded Moblin 2.1 onto my (beloved) EEE PC 700a to answer one question: is Moblin any good yet? Here’s what I discovered.

Pot-Moblin-Main

Performance & Drivers

The first thing I noticed was the blazing fast boot time. I thought I was seeing a boot screen, but no: the operating system had already booted within seconds. While the importance of fast boot times is sometimes overstated amongst geeks, a netbook is something that should start quickly. In this, the Moblin netbook OS delivers.

All the programs I ran while testing Moblin started noticeably faster than my usual operating system: Ubuntu Netbook Remix. Wireless, sound and video all worked perfectly out of the box. Nice work there, to be sure.

First Impression: “MyZone.”

When Moblin first starts up it automatically displays the “MyZone” page, one of the eight main panels that make up Moblin. MyZone features three main sections: your calendar, your recent history and your friend’s activities on the social networks.

Pot-Moblin-MyZone

While I personally would prefer the social networks be left off the home page completely, the three elements in combination seem like a logical starting-point for a netbook operating system: synthesising elements of online and offline content. After all, in this age of widely-accessible wireless Internet why should online content be limited to the browser?

That’s not to say MyZone is perfect yet. The calendar displayed is synced with various services, but I was disappointed to learn there’s no default way to sync with my calendar of choice – Google Calendar. Apparently this can be achieved using a subscription-based third party service called Goosync, but I’m hardly looking to pay money to access a free service.

As for compatible social networks, Moblin can currently display content from Twitter and Last.fm. More are presumably on the way, but if Facebook or LinkedIn integration is essential for you you’ll probably find the “MyZone” page less useful than intended for now.

Despite these shortcomings, however, Moblin’s first impression is a good one. MyZone combines elements of your online life – your friend’s comments on social networks, your browsing history and your calendar – with the documents you store and use on your netbook. Online and Offline content are integrated seamlessly.

The Toolbar

Rather than opting for the traditional, program-centric toolbar Moblin attempts to create a new paradigm, centred on the computer’s uses rather than on applications.

Pot-Moblin-Toolbar

The toolbar, hidden until the user moves the mouse to the top of the screen, consists of the time and date on the left followed by eight main buttons and four configuration tools. From right to left, the main buttons include MyZone, Status, People, Internet, Media, Pasteboard, Applications and Zones. Configuration buttons, to the right of these, include battery, volume, Bluetooth and network connectivity.

Pressing any of these buttons instantly brings up a system-integrated panel. Click the “Status” button, for example, and you can quickly update your social network status – currently only Twitter. If you’re a avid microblogger this kind of accessibility will doubtless strike you as useful.

Press the “People” button and you’ll see all your email and instant messaging contacts. Double-click one of them and you’ll open a new window to talk to them or an email window to write them. This is a good example of Moblin taking an existing open source program – in this case the instant-messaging application Empathy and the email program Evolution – and integrating them seamlessly into its own user interface.

Internet

Pressing the “Internet” button shows a quick panel allowing you to type a web address or click on one of your most commonly accessed web sites. Do so and the Moblin browser will open the page you’re looking for. I was seriously impressed with the browser. A huge improvement over Moblin 2, Moblin 2.1 includes a slick Mozilla-based browser optimized for usage on a netbook screen.

Pot-Moblin-Browser

This is the fastest browser I’ve ever run on my netbook””doubtless the result of the browser being optimised for the Intel Atom processor. But that’s not all. Not only is the browser attractive, clean and well-integrated into Moblin – it’s Mozilla based, meaning it’s compatible with Firefox plugins and add-ins. So essential plugins like Adobe Flash, Greasemonkey and Adblock Plus are all compatible with this browser.

One of the many strengths of open source software is the ability of one project to integrate components from another, and Moblin’s browser is a great example of this. Simply put, this is a netbook browser done right. Integrated into the rest of Moblin this gives Chrome OS a run for its money.

Media

Pressing the “Media” button brings up a simple user interface allowing you to quickly browse your videos, music and pictures.

Pot-Moblin-media

The interface is very intuitive. Insert an SD card with media files and this program will automatically find these files and point them out to you, allowing you to browse your media quickly and even search within it. Videos and pictures are automatically opened full-screen, very sensible for a netbook operating system running on systems with limited screen space.

This panel is simple, but that’s what it needs to be.

To the right of Media is Pasteboard. If you copy text or a picture in any program this is where it ends up. Unlike other operating systems, however, Moblin records a history of your copy-pasting, meaning if you copy over something you can retrieve it here. Simple idea but very useful in context.

Applications

Next up is Applications, which shows you a conventional menu where you can load locally-installed programs. Linux users will doubtlessly recognise the programs and games available. Note the contrast to Chrome OS, which does not allow the user to install programs on the local hard drive in favor of net apps. Moblin goes to no lengths to point out the programs, but it does allow users to install additional software and to use it. This is a great compromise between simplicity and customisability.

Longtime Linux users will be pleased to know that “Alt” and “F2″, a favorite shortcut of many, brings up the search button of the Applications panel, allowing users to type the name of their favourite program rather than browsing through the (quite annoying) application menu by mouse.

It’s also possible to install software from the Moblin repositories through a very easy-to-use interface. Currently there aren’t many applications available, but more are sure to come.

Pot-Moblin-Installation

Zones

The final main panel is Zones. When a program is opened in Moblin it is given its own workspace, or Zone, in which to operate. Clicking the Zone button on the panel will show you all the Zones currently open and allow you to switch between them, as well as moving programs from one Zone to another.

This may sound complicated on paper, but is actually a very elegant way to run multiple programs on a small screen.

Conclusion

Moblin is a very elegant and very fast netbook operating system, taking some of the best things about Linux and transforming it into a system perfect of Netbooks. The result is a very tight, well-thought-out system that combines the best of the offline and online worlds.

Philosophically, Moblin represents what I think is the perfect compromise between Google’s Chrome OS and traditional operating systems such as Windows or Ubuntu. While it’s simple and instantly easy to use in a manner similar to Chrome OS, it’s far easier to customise and extend””not to mention use offline.

But Moblin, for all its virtues, is not done yet. Installing third party applications isn’t easy, meaning installing Skype and Dropbox is out of the reach of most users (unless you’re running the Ubuntu version of Moblin, which is compatible with Ubuntu packages.)

But while Moblin might not be perfect yet, it’s certainly usable – but if it doesn’t yet meet your needs it’s certainly one worth waiting for. With a few tweaks it could easily become my netbook operating system of choice. I’ll be the first to write an article congratulating Intel and the Linux Foundation when it does.

Want to give Moblin a spin? You’ll need to download the image from Moblin, and then make a bootable disk using the image. You can learn how to do this using Moblin’s own detailed instructions, or you can use Unetbootin. I myself used Unetbootin and it worked great. Once you manage to boot from the image you can run Moblin directly from your disk or install it to your hard drive.

Have fun and make sure to leave your opinions about Moblin in the comments.

Justin Pot

Justin Pot is a blogger based in Boulder, Colorado who loves technology, people and nature. He tries to enjoy all three whenever possible. Check out JustinPot.com or, if you like audio, you can listen to Justin, alongside James and Dave, on Technophilia, earth's favorite Technology podcast.

The comments were closed because the article is more than 180 days old.

If you have any questions related to stuff mentioned in the article or need help with any computer issue, just ask it on MakeUseOf Answers.

Hide 29 Comments

  • pgkrzywy December 10, 2009
    0 likes

    i wont download it and install till i know one thing : is there chance to run a google chrome in it? i wont use any other browser (for now) – and im new to linux thing, so – can anyone share the secret with me? ;)
    Oh, one more thing : is there chance to have both Xp and Moblin on Msi Wind, dont loose a F3 recovery option and have access to Windows files via Moblin?
    And, can i install dropbox?
    Thanks! :)

    | Like
    • Justin Pot December 10, 2009
      0 likes

      I just got Chrome setup in Ubuntu and I love it, so I understand your concern. Happily Chromium, Chrome’s open-source cousin, is one of the few programs you can get in the easy-to-use Moblin application repository.

      I did manage to get Dropbox working in Moblin, but it’s not for the faint of heart–you’ll need to compile it from source. If there’s enough demand here maybe I’ll write a MakeUseOf article explaining how to do this. Alternatively, you can download the Ubuntu version of Moblin–Ubuntu Moblin Remix–and install the Ubuntu version of Dropbox just by double-clicking it like you do in Ubuntu.

      | Like
  • pgkrzywy December 10, 2009
    0 likes

    Thank you for your answer, i think that now i will try it… But (always is but) :)
    Recently i bought Huawei E220 3G Modem and i love it (and don’t use WiFi when im not at home) – is there chance to run Internet connection at Moblin (and any other linux in that case)? There is no Simlock, but i left Brand firmware (looks better 4me than original)
    If not, then it wont be as good as i think it would ;)

    | Like
    • Justin Pot December 10, 2009
      0 likes

      From what I can glean quickly online the Huawei E220 works well with Linux, but I’ve no idea how well it would work with Moblin. My suggestion is to give it a go with Moblin and to let our readers here know how it works by commenting down here. We’d love to hear how it goes!

      | Like
  • Will Owen December 11, 2009
    0 likes

    Have you not seen Jolicloud, it works on ubuntu and has everything you need. I won’t say it boots up that quickly (around 20 secs) though. Chrome and extensions work a treat :)

    | Like
    • Justin Pot December 11, 2009
      0 likes

      Unfortunately Jolicloud is invite-only at the moment, but I promise you we’ll take an in-depth look at that operating system as soon as it comes out. It’s certainly exciting seeing so many great projects grow around netbooks!

      | Like
  • Ashutosh Mishra December 11, 2009
    0 likes

    All these netbook-tailored, Linux-based OSes – Chrome OS, Moblin, Jolicloud, Ubuntu NBR – is really exiciting news. I haven;t tried any of these, but I’ll be sure to check one out when I get a netbook. :]

    | Like
  • Alex December 12, 2009
    0 likes

    I’ve installed yesterday moblin on my Acer Aspire One a110…
    th first thing that i notice is that every driver is workin! Also the webcam and Microphone…and i’ve fought a lot with linux gOS to install just the wifi..

    The boot from the USB is really fast..8 seconds…when i’ve installed it as primary OS it tooks 18seconds to boot and 1 minute to turn off…but this is due of SSD hard drive from acer…

    The system is pretty fast…but the applications available are so poor…no open office, no VLC…There is GIMP but is not the easy tool for a quick win image edit…

    The updates on the “desktop” are ust for Twitter and LastFM, and if you dont have those accounts you will have forever a right hole in the page.

    Also understanding that u cannot reboot but only turn off the system from the power button has been a lil bit dramatic…is a system that change the way u use normally the computers.

    I think the idea is fantastic: use the best of the online technology to connect in real time with your friends and stuffs, and also install applications with a physical hard drive to work offline. Chrome OS needs to learn from it…

    If moblin wants to rock the newtbook marketshare, needs to fix quickly a lot of bugs, missing items and software compatibility.

    Today i will try Jolicloud…seems that is similar to Moblin but the list of apps is wider…

    Greetings from Italy!

    Alex

    | Like
    • Justin Pot December 12, 2009
      0 likes

      Alex,

      Remember that Moblin is very much in testing yet; I think it’s safe to say that Moblin’s going to get a lot better before release. And if not having access to enough apps if your main problem you should consider Ubuntu Netbook Remix, which is Moblin but with access to the Ubuntu repositories.

      | Like
      • Alex December 12, 2009
        0 likes

        I know, and i will wait for my final decision.

        Today i saw that also chrome (that doesnt work fine for 9″) was into moblin and also Adobe Reader…probably OpenOffice will be released soon…

        Alex

        | Like
  • Rick December 12, 2009
    0 likes

    I tried the final release and thought it was a great start to something new. Fastest OS i’ve put on my eeePC 1000h…BY FAR, not even a close second place!

    Few things that keep me from using it.

    Codecs…no easy way of instsalling them and Intel or any third party has not provided any easy to follow step by step method. I have tried a few of the howto’s I found and alwasy get an error even though I am doing it just like the users claim they got it to work. I’m not a complete rookie in Linux but no pro either….but no codecs, no go for me.

    Also, the social idea is great, really…but without Facebook it is useless. I don’t know if it is something contractual with the Facebook company or what, but this needs to be implemented.

    | Like
  • JK III December 12, 2009
    0 likes

    I dont understand why netbooks require a special cloud OS. I am pretty sure any netbook would easily run Windows, Mac or Linux.

    My friend has a netbook (I think thats what it is, because it is a laptop, but smaller, and without a cd drive; I have only used it once :D ) and it runs XP without any problems.

    | Like
    • Alex December 13, 2009
      0 likes

      I’ve bought last year an Acer Aspire One a110 with SSD drive instead of Physical HDD and 1GB of RAM…

      The default system was XP and for it takes 2 minutes to boot and 3 to shut down…When a process was going on the pc was freezed…

      I’ve disinstall it and i used for months gOS, a linux distro…much more faster but not anymore supported and updated, so bugs, crashes and issues increase.

      Now im trying Moblin and Jolicloud…The first boot in 13 seconds and yesterday i was using firefox with 7 tabs at the same time without notice any slow performance. Jolicloud is a lil bit slower but it can works fine with my laptop..

      So repling to your question, some netbooks require special OS, because the future for me wont be 8GB of RAM but small resources on the device and all the job will be done into the cloud, from the sites and servers. My computer doesn’t have to scan every single file into the pages, the cloud will be my antivirus, and i dont have to install heavy tools like photoshop, because are coming online tools like that that will be faster and wont require too much resources.

      Alex

      | Like
  • Peter December 13, 2009
    0 likes

    How its about network conection Always working or some problem

    | Like
  • pgkrzywy December 13, 2009
    0 likes

    Yes, my msi wind run XP now too, but its kinda lame that i have to wait for bout 10 minutes to run a system. Tried ChromiumOS and it was cool to have working OS (ok, Chrome with WiFi button and a clokc) in couple od seconds from sd card…

    I am looking for something to work with internet only. Connection is not a problem – 3g modem and you can surf the net anywhere -> like now, i am writing to you from a bus.

    So, i wait for some v1.0, no betas. Only couple of things – 3g modem support, Chrome browser and access to my hdd files from XP :)

    | Like
  • lt December 13, 2009
    0 likes

    I’ve tried yesterday Moblin 2.1 on my eee 901. It run nicely and I’ve decided to replace UNR 9.10 with it basically fascinated with thhe 13sec boot and also somehow a bit disappointed with my UNR that blocked my machine already twice whenn resuming from suspend (something that UNR 9.04 never did, by the way).

    I was kind of happy but I started to observe something that I cannot explain and the really annoyed me. My wireless frequently went off and again frequently did not re-connected giving some unable to connect error. This does not occur with UNR or with any of my laptops on the same network, so this is clearly some problem with Moblin. It’s a pitty, as the bug is still there even after updating Moblin to its most recent packages. I liked the concept and I was willing to stay with it for some time even though I also miss fast links to facebook and the like. Anyway I’ll wait for better times but for now I’m back to UNR 9.10…

    | Like
  • www.libros2012.net February 8, 2010
    0 likes

    wwwlibros2012net

    | Like