Pinterest Stumbleupon Whatsapp
Ads by Google

It’s that time of year. Long lines outside electronics stores, rabid shoppers, and a mad scramble for products…oh, I’m not talking about the holidays. I’m talking about the launch of two new consoles.

The PlayStation 4 PS4 vs Xbox One: 5 Reasons To Buy The PS4 PS4 vs Xbox One: 5 Reasons To Buy The PS4 E3 2013 marked the moment when the next-generation truly began, with all three contenders -- the PlayStation 4 (PS4), Xbox One, and Wii U -- revealed in full. The Wii U is already on the... Read More and Xbox One PS4 vs Xbox One: 5 Reasons To Buy The Xbox One PS4 vs Xbox One: 5 Reasons To Buy The Xbox One This year's E3 felt almost like it was over before it began. Though the conference lasts for days, both Microsoft and Sony made their announcements before the doors opened, showing not just hardware but also... Read More are launching in North America and will have launched in most countries throughout the world by summer of next year. Gamers are understandably excited; excluding the Wii U, which hasn’t found much of a following, a new console hasn’t arrived in eight years. That’s a long time to wait, but should you spend your money now? Or should you wait a bit longer?

The Hardware

ps4

Consoles are standardized platforms, so their core hardware, miniaturization aside, generally remains unchanged throughout the console’s life. That doesn’t mean other changes aren’t made, however; since its original release both the Xbox 360 and the PlayStation 3 have seen several significant revisions.

The changes usually impact size, cooling and reliability. The original Xbox 360, despite a loud fan, suffered from a heat-related failure known as the “red ring of death” How To Care For Your Xbox 360 & Fix A Dead Console How To Care For Your Xbox 360 & Fix A Dead Console Read More because of the console’s ring of blinking red lights that indicate when something go wrong. Sony’s PlayStation 3 proved more reliable, but it was extremely large and loud at launch, problems that have since been curtailed.

redring

Ads by Google

While the new consoles are built to be a bit less obtrusive than their predecessors, these same concerns remain. The PlayStation 4, for example, registers 42 decibels of noise from one meter away; not absurd, but certainly noticeable. The PS4 also creates about as much heat and draws more power than the latest version of the PS3. The Xbox One was not tested at time of this publishing, but we do know it’s a beefy piece of kit that’s both wider and longer than the original 360.

In short, you’ll receive better hardware if you wait for each console’s first revision. You’ll also reduce the risk of running across any early production run glitches. Neither issue is likely to deter hardcore gamers, but casual players will likely prefer smaller, quieter second-run versions of the PS4 and Xbox One.

The Software

New software has bugs. That’s a fact of life that PC gamers have long grown accustomed to that console fans are just now starting to learn. Two generation ago, when consoles had almost no user-facing interface, bugs weren’t such a concern. But today’s more powerful and functional systems run a sizable operating system, which creates the opportunity for bugs to creep in.

While the Xbox One wasn’t launched at the time of this writing, the PlayStation 4 was, and users have already started to report issues like freezing, stuttering and random reboots. And while some like the PS4’s new operating system, others have had issues with the functionality of core feature design.

xbox360originaldash

While software design certainly offers room for a difference of opinion, it’s likely that the launch version of each next-gen console operating system will be the worst, least functional version of the operating system that retail units will ever run. Just look at the Xbox 360 and PS3; the software on both has changed radically since launch.

This is another trait that hardcore gamers are unlikely to care about. They’ll be playing games, after all. Those who rely on their console as a media center Which Game Consoles Can You Use as a Media Center? Which Game Consoles Can You Use as a Media Center? Looking at Microsoft and Sony's next generation offerings, it seems that bringing video, TV, music and your photo collection (and probably social networking) into the mix of games and achievement unlocking is now part and... Read More , however, may want to hold off until the updates are released.

The Games

This is where the hardcore gamers run into a problem.

The launch title line-up for both consoles did not look bad at their respective announcements in early 2013. Since then, however, some titles have been moved back, while others have had content cut, or show signs of being unfinished. My personal favorite, Forza 5 for the Xbox One, is coming to market with half the cars and tracks of Forza 4, released two years ago on the Xbox 360. The PS4’s launch lineup, meanwhile, has been torn apart by critics.

playstation4metacritic

Disappointing though it may be, this is a predictable result.  The Xbox 360’s launch line-up included gems like Perfect Dark Zero, while the PS3’s only respectable exclusive was Resistance: Fall Of Man. Even the wildly successful PlayStation 2 lacked a stand-out game during its United States launch.

The problem with any console launch is that game development rarely sticks to schedule, but the release of each console puts a serious deadline on when the title needs to be done. While delays do occur, most developers that sign up for launch make the release, even if it means cutting back content or features.

This makes it hard to recommend buying either the PS4 or the Xbox One for the games. And since backwards compatibility has been cut from both, you won’t have much reason to turn either on after you finish the few meager titles available.

Conclusion

You don’t have to be a psychic to predict where this conclusion is heading. While buying a console at launch can be hugely exciting for any gamer, it also leaves you with the worst version of the console, for which you’ve paid the highest price. And, as if that weren’t enough, there are hardly any games to play on it!

The smart money is on waiting until big-name franchises like Halo and Uncharted make their arrival. Besides offering gameplay that is already known and loved, big-studio releases that come out a six months to a year after launch are more likely to make proper use of each console’s hardware.

That’s not to say you’d be a fool to buy now, though. If you have the money, and the desire, there’s no shame in getting wrapped up in the hype of new hardware. Gamers on a budget, however, should keep their wallets shut.

  1. Didier
    November 21, 2013 at 7:52 am

    Thank you for sharing your toughts.

    In my opinion, you should also mention that it took 1 year and 9 months to see the price of the Xbox 360 decreasing by only 20$ (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xbox_360). On the other hand, it took less than a year for the PS3 to see the price dropping but the console was very expensive at launch and arrive on the market far later than Xbox 360 so they had to do it.

    I honestly prefer to switch to the new console as soon as possible for this litle price difference. About technical issue we have the warranty for that so that's not a problem in my opinion.

  2. Suleiman O
    November 19, 2013 at 6:44 pm

    I will go a bit off the topic but it is related:

    You forgot to mention PS3's YLOD aka yellow light of death. My PS3 was working fine all the years till i made the last update. In few weeks after the update the YLOD showed up. Could it be that PS made us download a patch that over heats further more our system so they can stop working and later we drain out money to buy PS4? To fix YLOD you literary have to dismantle your PS3 to its motherboard and work on thermal pads and the thermal pastes. PS3 has one big fan and with little ventilation. I wonder how they resolve the heat issue on PS4 which is more powerful and smaller in size than the 60GB fat PS3.

    ....back to the topic:

    I would rather buy my console on its release day. If problems arise PS will resolve them with updates. The only time i will not update it would be few months before PS5's release day, for i don't want to end up getting YLOD :) ( PS: i am not sure the cause of my PS3's YLOD was the last update i made, i am just guessing cuz i am pissed off :) )

    • Matt S
      November 19, 2013 at 8:38 pm

      I completely forgot about YLOD. Probably because I didn't grab a PS3 until last year, but I did go through three Xbox 360s, all of which died to RROD.

  3. likefunbutnot
    November 19, 2013 at 2:23 pm

    As a mild rebuttal to this, early PS3s are vastly more capable and interesting devices than later models, albeit not for their expected purpose. I spent a considerable amount of time and money tracking down a Playstation 3 that could play Super Audio CDs while still using a firmware revision old enough to allow me to boot Linux on it. I was primarily interested in the ability to rip SACDs, but I also discovered that it's only those oldest Playstation models that have full backward compatibility with PS1 and PS2 games. In the process of streamlining their manufacture, Sony ultimately dropped SACD support, Linux compatibility and the ability to run older games from newer models.

    Of course, the new consoles coming on to the market now are essentially simple PCs that don't support backward compatibility or any interesting media playback features in the first placeand something something glorious PC master race comments also apply here.

    • Matt S
      November 19, 2013 at 8:33 pm

      That's a good counterpoint. I do wonder if, given the hardware, we'll see some interesting hacks of the next-gen consoles. Can an Xbox One or PS4 be made to run Windows, for example? And if it could, how hard would manufacturers will try hard to crack down on that? I'm eager to see what the hacker community comes up with.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *