It goes without saying that everyone needs to use stronger passwords, and the best way to do that is with a password manager. The truth is, passwords that are hard to hack are just as hard to remember, yet even so, you really do need long and complex passwords.
That’s where password managers come in handy. There are all kinds of password managers out there, including some as basic as your browser’s rudimentary list of saved passwords list and some as elaborate as entire cloud systems that work across multiple devices and platforms.
All of these models have some basics in common: they store your passwords, they auto-fill details on login forms, and they keep your passwords encrypted in databases. The differences are where those databases are kept, the types of encryption and recovery options available.
Weaponized Math: Encrypted Passwords
Your browser can save passwords, but that often isn’t very secure. One of the main appeals of a password manager is that it saves all of your passwords behind one password in a single database.
Of course putting all your plain text passwords in one place isn’t much of a security measure in and of itself. Instead, your passwords must be encrypted, which secures your passwords. But since the amount of control over password databases can vary, you’ll want to figure out which model works best for you.
When boiled down, encryption is the use of math to disguise your data. The key used to transform the plaintext is randomly generated, the strength of the encryption is based on this key size in bits. In layman’s terms: the more bits, the more security. This is because the more compelx the key, the more complex the resulting output is.
Depending on the algorithm, that substitution is repeated. In certain cases, they key is transformed to further obscure the output. This process is creates what’s called a hash, which often has added salt—additional randomization added to the hashing process. This ensures the original value is completely obscured without the correct starting input, key, and salt.
There are additional factors like block size, initialization vectors, and other more advanced concepts. If you’re interested in the gory details, check out our detailed breakdown of encryption.
Local Safes: Keeping Control
The best way to keep a secret is to never tell anyone. If you don’t want your passwords anywhere other than on your hard drive, a local password manager is your best option. This keeps your data on a device that you physically control, leaving your security directly in your own hands.
One of the more popular password managers is KeePass, an open source Windows solution with ports on Mac and Linux. It offers a lot of flexibility and control, including the ability to select between multiple encryption algorithms.
And if you’re looking for a complete escape from passwords, you can even use key files to unlock your passwords. (You put key files on a USB drive or other portable storage, then use the physical device as a key to authenticate with the machine.)
The downside to KeePass is the same as its strengths: you control the keys to the kingdom, so if you lose your key files or master password, you’re out of luck. In such a case, your only option would be to start over from scratch and set up every password again.
Your file is also limited to where you save it, so you’re responsible for any backups you want to maintain. If you want mobile sync, you’re going to need to do it manually (or with a separate syncing service like Dropbox) and a compatible reader on your tablet/phone. And if something goes wrong, you’re on your own.
Local managers give you a lot of security and control, but you lose a rescue plan and out-of-the-box portability.
Syncing Systems: Multiple Devices
If you’re juggling multiple devices with many passwords, keeping a master file locked on a PC somewhere is not the best solution — especially if you’re trying to log into Amazon on your phone or check your bank balance on your tablet. Don’t weaken the password just to make it more memorable!
That’s where hybrid approaches like 1Password come in, which uses Dropbox or your local network to automatically sync your password between devices. This gives you the ability to keep everything working across devices, but you are still the only one with the key to your data.
But you lose some of the crunchier options, such as multiple encryption algorithms and key file logins.
This fixes a lot of the downsides of the local-only option, as you can keep your phone, tablet, and computer all in sync. You’ll also need to trust Dropbox as a cloud host, though 1Password does add an extra layer of security on top with its own strong encryption, so you can rest assured of any security worries.
If you’re really worried about interceptors and other vectors of attack, you can just use your local network to synchronize your passwords across devices. You won’t have any hope of recovering a lost master password if you choose this route, but it does ensure that 1Password won’t have access either.
Cloud Services: Any Device, Anywhere
Keeping all of your passwords in the cloud requires a certain amount of trust in a company to do things the right way. Then again, some users couldn’t care less about that. Even after a big hacking incident, a lot of people still use LastPass. Go figure.
LastPass keeps an encrypted copy of your password database in the cloud, making it available on almost every platform and browser imaginable. You will need a premium membership for several of their features, but the basics are there for free.
Your devices do all of the encryption and decryption, ensuring that your master password is not on LastPass’s servers. If you don’t have access to the Web, a copy is cached locally so you can still unlock. There is an additional layer of protection in two-step verification as well.
You have to trust their security is as robust as promised, as LastPass makes for an obvious target for hackers. However, with a good master password and two-step verification enabled, you should be confident about the security of your password safe. And if you ever forget your password, you can recover your safe.
Literally the Least You Can Do
If you’re a Mac and/or iOS user, you already have access to a password manager built into your operating system: iCloud Keychain. This is an extension of the OS X keychain that uses iCloud to keep all of your passwords synced across devices.
Windows has a similar feature called Credential Manager, but it does not have the same cross-device syncing.
This is pretty comparable in terms of security to LastPass, but it’s limited to Apple devices. Unless you’re only running exclusively on Apple products, you’re going to be missing your passwords on some of your other devices, which can be a huge nuisance.
Yet even if you’re a big Apple fan, you still may not want to lock yourself into the platform because you never know what kind of other devices you may get in the future.
You Really Need a Password Manager
Unless you have an iron-clad memory, using different passwords across all of your accounts is going to prove difficult. Doing so with hard-to-crack passwords? Near impossible. Getting a password manager ensures that you can keep all of your accounts safe and secure using a single master password.
Find the model that works best with you and find the product that works best for your devices. Almost every manager has a free trial or free tier that you can try out. Once you’ve made your choice, go through all of your online accounts and update the passwords to be more complex. That’s really all there is to it.
If we overlooked your favorite password manager let us know what it is and why it’s your favorite in the comments.
Image Credit: Bank Vault Door by KEG via Shutterstock, Ljupco Smokovski via Shutterstock, R. Mackay Photography, LLC via Shutterstock, higyou via Shutterstock, Plus69 via Shutterstock, Stephane Bidouze via Shutterstock