Google Play vs. Amazon Appstore: Which Is Better?

Ads by Google

google play vs amazon app storeAndroid comes with Google Play, but that isn’t the only app store you can use on Android. Android allows users to use third-party app stores, and Amazon has stepped up with a competitor of its own — the Amazon Appstore for Android. Once US-only, the Amazon Appstore is now available in nearly 200 countries around the world and is a true, global competitor to Google Play.

The Amazon Appstore for Android isn’t just a third-party app store for Android devices. It’s also the place to get apps for Amazon’s Kindle Fire tablets and, perhaps, the rumored Amazon Kindle smartphone that may be released in the future.

Convenience

There’s no getting around this — Google Play is included with your Android phone or tablet, while the Amazon Appstore must be installed from Amazon’s website. Adding the Amazon Appstore gives you a second app store with a different software-updating process. Having two app stores and two app-updating process is just less convenient than having a single one, so the Amazon Appstore has to offer compelling reasons to install and use it.

Winner: Google Play

google play vs amazon app store

Free Apps

To make itself attractive, the Amazon Appstore offers a “free app of the day” every day. These are paid apps available free for a single day. Grab a free app and you’ll even be able to install it for free in the future.

The free apps often vary from utilities you’d never use to little-known Android games. However, Amazon has also offered some popular apps, such as the paid versions of Cut The Rope Experiments and Fruit Ninja. Overall, it’s a mixed bag. It’s hard to argue with free apps, but this is fundamentally a way to get you opening the Amazon Appstore every day.

Ads by Google

If you want an app, it often only costs $0.99 on Google Play or you may be able to get a free, ad-supported version. It may not be worth staking out the Amazon Appstore for, given that you may not be interested in the free app most days.

You can get notifications of the free Amazon app of the day with an app like the Free App Notifier For Amazon, which is amusingly only available on Google Play. If you’d like free apps on Google Play, try AppGratis, which offers a free app every day along with steep discounts and giveaways for freemium apps.

Winner: Amazon Appstore

google play vs. amazon apps

Quantity of Apps

There’s no getting around the app selection problem. According to the most recent available reports, Google Play has over 700,000 Android apps while the Amazon Appstore has about 75,000 — much, much fewer. If you’re looking for an app, you’ll have much more selection available to you in Google Play. The Amazon Appstore offers many big-name apps, but more niche apps — perhaps the app for your bank or less-popular utilities — will likely only be available in Google Play. Given that the Amazon Appstore was only available in the US for so long, it’s likely that apps for local services in countries outside the US will likely only be available in Google Play.

The Amazon appstore doesn’t really offer any exclusive apps — you’ll find paid, ad-free versions of the first few Angry Birds games on the Amazon Appstore but not on Google Play, but that’s about it.

Winner: Google Play

App Discovery

Google Play offers recommended apps based on the apps you’ve used, frequently updated curated lists of the best Android apps, and a more modern interface. The Amazon appstore offers no app recommendations or such curated lists, leaving you to search and view the most popular free and paid apps.

Google Play’s interface is far better for browsing the store and discovering new apps, although it’s a much larger store to browse while the Amazon Appstore’s is much smaller.

Winner: Google Play

google play vs. amazon apps

Ecosystem Integration

Google Play is integrated with every popular Android device you might by, excluding the cheapest tablets and phones. Sign into an Android device and all your apps will be accessible from Google Play. They can even be automatically installed and restored onto your Android device when you factory-reset it or buy a new one.

If you opt for the Amazon Appstore, you’ll have to install the Amazon Appstore on each new Android device, sign in, and install your apps. This isn’t the most integrated experience.

However, if you have a Kindle Fire, you may prefer the Amazon Appstore anyway. Apps you purchase on the Amazon appstore can be used on both your Kindle Fire and Android smartphone, giving Amazon’s Appstore a leg up over Google Play.

google play vs. amazon apps

Amazon is also rumored to be working on its own Kindle smartphone. If you can see yourself using an Amazon Kindle phone in the future, purchasing apps on the Amazon Appstore may be smart — you’ll probably be able to use them on your future Kindle phone, while apps purchased on Google Play will be more difficult to install.

There’s no clear winner here: If you’re an Android user first-and-foremost, you’ll want to stay in the Google Play ecosystem. If you’re a Kindle user first and foremost, you’ll get benefits from using the Amazon Appstore.

You can root your Kindle Fire and install Google Play, but that isn’t the most convenient experience.

Winner if you prefer Android Devices: Google Play

Winner if you prefer Kindle Devices: Amazon Appstore

The Winner

Ultimately, the Amazon Appstore has some big disadvantages — less-convenient setup, far fewer available apps, and a worse interface for discovering new apps. Most people will probably prefer to use Google Play, simplifying their lives by sticking to the app store included with their Android devices.

However, the Amazon Appstore does have some advantages. Its free app of the day will appeal to bargain-conscious users who love snapping up free apps. Its integration with Amazon’s Kindle Fire will appeal to Kindle Fire owners and users dreaming of future Amazon smartphones and tablets, allowing them to use their apps across their Android and Kindle devices.

If you’re just looking for a convenient app store, you’ll be happy with Google Play. If you love grabbing free apps or prefer Amazon’s Kindle hardware, you may be better off purchasing apps on the Amazon Appstore. Prices are similar on both app stores, so that isn’t a factor.

If you do have one of the cheapest Android devices that doesn’t come with Google Play, you may want to install the Amazon Appstore and use it instead of Google Play. There are also workarounds that may allow you to install Google Play on your device, but this is much more complex. It’s much easier to install the Amazon Appstore.

If you’ve used both, what’s your take between Google Play vs Amazon Appstore? Which one do you prefer? Did we miss any advantages the Amazon Appstore has over Google Play? Leave a comment and let us know!

Join live MakeUseOf Groups on Grouvi App Join live Groups on Grouvi
Best Android Phones
Best Android Phones
5 Members
Best Android Games
Best Android Games
17 Members
Best Android Apps
Best Android Apps
29 Members
Android Rooting and ROMs
Android Rooting and ROMs
25 Members
Android OS Tips
Android OS Tips
22 Members
Android Rumors and News
Android Rumors and News
9 Members
Best Android Tablets
Best Android Tablets
4 Members
Ads by Google
Comments (30)
  • safa

    In the last week I have ran into two apps that are not up to date. There are newer versions in the google play store, but not on amazon app store. This has been an on going problem but has never affected me so much before. The two apps in question are star command and GTA: vice city. I am running a nexus 7 2013 LTE with android 5.0.2. Both apps need the newest update from the developer and amazon store is way behind. Until I see improvements in the app versions, I will not be making further purchases. Please provide up to date apps.

  • jim

    I have installed several apps from Amazon appstore. Now whenever I try opening one of theses games I get error “you do notoenthis app”. VERY irritated with this!!!!! I will NEVER use amazon appstore again!!!

  • Dan Owens

    the Amazon app store only advantage is that you get a free app of a day but like the reviewer said its a crap app most of the time. I have found that with any device I have had weather be low end or high end devices Google just works all of their apps seem to work flawlessly and seem to have features paid apps don’t and they’re free. Google itself has apps for just about anything you would need to do personally. With the Amazon App Store you cannot download any Google Apps and if you decide you do not want to have the Amazon app store you cannot use the apps installed from said app store. and besides just about every paid app has a free app on Google Play.
    Google play all the way

  • Myra R

    i have a question say i were playing a game i had downloaded from the google play store (Myvegas) then i made an in app purchase with a google play gift card then once that purchase went through and i got what i payed for added to my game (Myvegas) what if i uninstalled the game app (Myvegas) and reinstalled it from the amazon app store will the things i purchased carry over?? also this game connects via your facebook account so i am thinking it will stick with me but i dont wanna spend any money without being sure?? cause i dont have a credit card or anything and no where around where i live sells amazon gift cards but they sell google play store cards so i was thinking this might work?? i googled around trying to find the answer but its unconventional so i thought maybe you would be able to help? the reason why i would want to uninstall the google option and switch to amazon is because the game has better features through amazon then through the google play store. thanks for your time!!

    • Dan Owens

      some games will if you have to login inside the game with your Facebook account on your Google Play account then yes it will safe and you should get whatever you had on your new device. But this is not the case with all games I would suggest contacting the developer and asking them this way you get a thorough answer.

  • Menamcore

    I cant use my apps offline on amazon total rubbish uninstalled

Load 10 more
Affiliate Disclamer

This review may contain affiliate links, which pays us a small compensation if you do decide to make a purchase based on our recommendation. Our judgement is in no way biased, and our recommendations are always based on the merits of the items.

For more details, please read our disclosure.
Affiliate Disclamer

This review may contain affiliate links, which pays us a small compensation if you do decide to make a purchase based on our recommendation. Our judgement is in no way biased, and our recommendations are always based on the merits of the items.

For more details, please read our disclosure.