Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?

fbads   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?I honestly never thought that I’d be paying for any sort of advertising for my blog, at least not until it entered into the “big time”, with many hundreds of thousands of pageviews per day. I never really believed that the cost of advertising on a small scale could really be worth the results. If you only invest less than $10 a day into an advertising campaign, can it really have any impact at all? Don’t most advertising campaigns require hundreds of dollars a month or more?

This is the question that I set out to answer at the beginning of this year. My goal was to start out small – only investing $8 per day. Not like the big advertising entities that Justin wrote about not long ago. The goal of my advertising campaign would be only to gain traffic at my site, not to sell anything or funnel traffic to a single “conversion” page. My hope was that the “seeding” of incoming traffic from the dozens of clicks on the ad would gradually build up a snowballing collection of loyal readers. That was the plan.

In this article, I’m going to share the results of my tests. The tests involved individually running a Facebook advertising campaign costing approximately $8 per day for a couple of months. I discussed how to set this up in a previous article about Facebook advertising. Next, I initiated a Google Adwords campaign for $8 per day for a couple of months. I’ll show you how I set up each advertising campaign, and reveal the final results – comparing Facebook advertising head-to-head against Google Adwords advertising. You can be the judge as to which investment is better for a small-scale blogger.

Facebook Ads vs. Google Adwords

I should disclose up front that I am by no means an advertising or marketing expert. My expertise in the domain of drawing in traffic is focused on SEO techniques, and the world of online advertising was relatively foreign to me up until January of this year.

Testing Facebook Advertising

Diving into Facebook Ads was only frustrating at the very start, because it took the Facebook team an annoyingly long time to approve my ads. I started out trying to create a static ad for my site, until I stumbled upon an interesting advertising option Facebook offers where they will dynamically create a new ad every time you publish a new post update on your Facebook page.

advertising1a   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
This not only avoids the need to have to invest time in developing an eye-catching ad that encourages clicks, but I also found that it really seems to encourage clickthroughs by a larger population of Facebook users. If one post subject doesn’t attract a lot of people, you only have to wait until your next page post – that ad could very well attract a crowd. This ability to dynamically publish post ads is, in my opinion, one of the biggest advantages about Facebook advertising. It is exceedingly convenient.

Also, Facebook has nice performance feedback reports. I’ve seen some big numbers here – with hundreds of thousands of impressions reported and thousands of clicks, but it’s really hard to verify these numbers, because those clicks go to your Facebook page, not your website.

advertising1b   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
You can create ads on Facebook that go directly to your website, but I found within just a week that the click-through performance was nowhere near the sort of numbers you can get from using the dynamic post engagement ads. So, after that first week, I switched to post engagement, established a limit of $8 per day, and waited to see what the results were like.

As far as accumulating Facebook page “likes” go, Facebook ads are the single-most effective ways to build an audience on Facebook. It is remarkable how quickly I was able to accumulate fans on the Facebook page – starting from just a few days after starting the advertising campaign. 133 likes on just one day that first month, and that was after getting only 2 or 3 likes per day before advertising.

advertising4   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
I was definitely curious to see if the Facebook page traffic resulting from that advertising would have any effect on my site traffic, since that was really my ultimate goal here. What I noticed is that whenever there was a Facebook post that attracted a lot of interest, I definitely got a nice spike in Facebook referral traffic. In my case, that amounted to a hundred to two hundred folks per spike, but when you’re struggling to build traffic levels by a few hundred readers at a time, those spikes help tremendously. They bring new people to your site, and they can contribute to your growth over the long-term. Obviously, if you want more traffic, you’d increase your investment proportionally.

advertising6   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
Over the long-term, I could see that I wasn’t imagining things. Over the course of about three months, you could see how before I began the Facebook advertising campaign, my site traffic was relatively flat. There was slow, steady growth, but no frequent spikes in interest. That all changed after starting the Facebook advertising campaign in January. I could see frequent spikes in my overall site traffic that coincided with the referral spikes from Facebook.

advertising8   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
I was sold on Facebook advertising after the first month, and I continue to use it to this day. I love that I never really have to think about my ads, I just try to make interesting posts that may go viral, and hope that the post ad catches a lot of eyes and gets them to click, and ultimately discover my page and my site for the first time.

Google Adwords Advertising

Google Adwords was an entirely different beast. I’d been receiving $100 coupons for quite a while from Google as encouragement to launch my first advertising campaign. Of course, once I went to start using Adwords, I couldn’t find a single one of those coupons. Figures.

There’s a little bit more of a learning curve with Adwords than there is with Facebook. There are actually people out there that specialize in creating and running Adwords campaigns, so this is by no means a full-blown, professional test. The goal here was to create a very simple 1-ad campaign with a small budget and see how it performed compared to Facebook using the same budget. It turned out creating an ad wasn’t all that hard, and the steps are laid out in the tabs that you find in Adwords.

advertising1c   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
You start out building an Ad Group, and establish your daily budget for it in the settings tab. Then you move on to the Ads tab and upload the ad you created using your favorite image software. In this test, I created a basic image ad with some interesting text and a compelling call to action.  The ad was approved in just a day or so, as opposed to getting my first ad approved on Facebook, which took about a week.

advertising1d   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
Then, you need to dive into the heart of what makes Adwords work – the keyword phrases that you want to bid on. You need to choose these wisely. They should be phrases that are extremely popular, but also ones that are very relevant to your own site content – this way when people are on a website that is focused on those keywords, they’ll see your ad and they’ll be far more likely to click on it, because your ad serves up more content related to their interests.

advertising1e   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
You can just imagine that your choice of keywords – and the quality of your ad of course – will have a significant impact on your ad performance. In this test, I chose keywords that I knew were relevant to my site based on what Google listed in my Webmasters account, and that I also knew were very popular in the search engines from some of my past research.

Just as in the case of Facebook, I saw almost instant results. Also similar to Facebook, the claimed impressions were quite high, but in the case of Google Adwords, the clickthrough rates weren’t quite as impressive. While Facebook had ad-clicks of 40 to 150 per day, the Google ad averaged a steady 35 to 50 per day with no real spikes to speak of.

advertising2   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
Again, these are the same costs, but a clear difference in click-through rates for each ad. This could probably be explained by the fact that the Facebook ads are based on posts and often times more enticing to click on than a standard, static ad.

advertising1   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
To get a clearer picture of how these two ad services impacted traffic at the blog, I took a closer look at whether Google had a similar impact to site traffic as Facebook did. So, checking out Google Analytics around the time that I launched the first Google Ad campaign, I saw just an initial spike right after the ad campaign started, and then it tapered back down to nearly no impact.

advertising5   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
Unlike the regular spikes of incoming traffic that I can see coming from the Facebook referrals every now and then, I saw pretty much zero impact to the site traffic from the Google Adwords campaign.
advertising7   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?
However, Google Adwords does offer a nice, reliable clickthrough rate on a daily basis – which means if your goal is to drive people to a single sales page or some other page that can successfully convert visitors to buyers, Adwords may be a great resource. For $8, I can get nearly 50 people a day to visit a page and potentially buy something. For a larger investment, that could go up. With an even better ad, that could skyrocket.

However, as a way to drive traffic and grow site readership, a low investment at Adwords just doesn’t have the same impact as a small investment at Facebook. Even better, the impact to page likes has been tremendous. It took nearly two years to hit 1,000 likes on the blog Facebook page. After just a few months of Facebook advertising, that skyrocketed to over 11,000 fans – and the growth isn’t slowing at all.

advertising9   Facebook Ads vs Google Adwords: Which One Got Me The Most Clicks?

That growth means a significant audience on Facebook, which will most certainly convert to very nice traffic spikes when particularly viral posts are published. That is the real beauty of Facebook advertising – it may not have a huge, direct impact on site traffic right away, but it grows your Facebook following quickly. That alone provides for a very strong foundation for your website growth.

It should be obvious by now that my selection of a winner between Facebook ads vs Google Adwords is Facebook. However, that’s for traffic growth. If this were a campaign to sell an item online, that could change the entire game, and it’s definitely worth  a future experiment.

Do you use either Facebook Ads or Google Adwords? What has been your experience with the services? Did you find great success with one or the other? Share your experiences and tips in the comments section below!

Image Credit: Advertising Megaphone Via Shutterstock

The comments were closed because the article is more than 180 days old.

If you have any questions related to what's mentioned in the article or need help with any computer issue, ask it on MakeUseOf Answers—We and our community will be more than happy to help.

15 Comments -

0 votes

Joel Lee

I don’t know if I’ll ever get into the advertising market but that was pretty interesting to read nonetheless.

I’m not very comfortable with Facebook (haven’t been for a while) so I think I’d go with Google if I ever needed to choose. Like you said, there are entire businesses built on running Google campaigns for clients, so perhaps it’s just a matter of optimization? Kinda like AdSense, which also requires optimization and research in order to perform well.

Anyway, thanks for sharing, Ryan. Loved it!

0 votes

Ryan Dube

Yup – I do agree with you that when it comes to Google it’s probably just a matter of optimizing with the right keywords and ad configuration. In fact, after I placed my first ad, the Adwords team emailed me and offered to help with that, so they’re clearly catering to folks willing to spend money to advertise – even the “little guy”.

What I liked about Facebook was the simplicity and how fast/easy it was to start building an audience and fan-base very fast.

0 votes

Sabrina

Thank you for your insights! I am not an advertising expert either, so I was curious to read about your experiences. I work as a sales manager of two hotels in Vienna, Austria (Rainers Hotel and Senator Hotel). Besides sales, I am responsible for our homepages and social media pages and am currently thinking about using Facebook Ads, too (so far, we only are only using Google AdWords through an agency). After reading your blog, I will definitely suggest Facebook Ads to my GMs. Thanks :)

0 votes

Ryan Dube

Great! Glad to help Sabrina. Keep in mind that Facebook really also requires good, healthy posting activity. So if you do take the approach I took and use the dynamic ads that Facebook offers (ads built on your latest post), then make sure to post at least once a day so your new ad will be created and circulate Facebook for 24 hours.

I suspect too many different ads per day might be too much – and won’t give the individual ads time to work, but I haven’t experimented with that enough to know either way.

0 votes

Ryan Stroud

Hi Ryan (great name!)

I have just started looking into advertising online, and this post has made my mind up for me! Facebook all the way, i’m looking to build a following and brand awareness!

Thanks for the info mate

Ryan – http://www.followussocial.co.uk

0 votes

macwitty

We have used Adwords a couple of times with okay result. Have never looked deeper into Facebook ads but it seems as it is something we should do

0 votes

Sonesh Lakhani

I think facebook ads are more effective

0 votes

Guy McDowell

Thank you for this article. I’ll be using it in my next Web Team meeting at work. Some pretty wise information here.

0 votes

Salvador

It’s funny, I’ve basically had the same experience as you in the last couple weeks. I found advertising a post to be the most effective way of advertising by B&B on Facebook. CPC rates are way lower than the traditional sidebar ads and it allows me to put a link to my site in the advertised post. So, people who click on the post can either go to my page (where they can engage with other fans, like the page, or book) or my site where they can look a pics, etc and book as well. So far I’ve only been paying 0.02 a click. Even the users who get to my site from Facebook have been much more engaged than Adwords users. I tried Adwords before for another business and had the same results. I found Adwords especially bad for Display Network ads. Ads in search results drove somewhat more engaged users, but still less so than Facebook for a higher price. My keywords are very targeted as well, so I don’t get a whole lot of clicks, but even when I do they’re just to producing.

0 votes

Ryan Dube

Interesting feedback – thanks Salvador. It would be interesting to experiment with that and collect more data on how interactive and engaged users that are drawn in from each source are with the site. Google Analytics might help with that – interesting concept!

0 votes

Sebastian Aiden Daniels

Great Post. I am new to blogging, but I have might to check out the Facebook ads thing for my blog. I don’t have a facebook page, but maybe I’ll start one. I have just started using Outbrain which puts links on sites like CNN.com and such. You should check it out.

Thank you for this valuable information.

0 votes

Elogicsoft

This is a great article comparing 2 internet giants. I think both are good yet i am only using Google Adwords. Whether Facebook ads are helpful getting business? or it is a long term process! Any suggestion.

Thank You.

0 votes

Sandi Pinkney

Thanks so much for the information it was very helpful. For a small business we need to invest our advertising monies wisely. You gave insight into the difference between Adwords and Facebook Ads. Again thanks….I think we are going to try the Facebook Ads Campaign first.

0 votes

Kevin

Hi Ryan, Thanks for the detailed comparison. I saw you’re up to almost 30K Facebook followers now. Congrats! How have Facebook Ads and Google AdWords played into the steep growth?

0 votes

Ryan Dube

Thanks Kevin. Well, for many months I kept paying the monthly Facebook ads fee and Likes grew rapidly up to over 18,000 or so. At that point, I needed to make some cuts to my budget so I slashed Facebook ad money and hoped it wouldn’t completely stall growth. To my surprise, now that we’re at that number of followers, there is still decent growth with each update.

I attempted Google Adwords for a while, but it really didn’t have much impact on traffic for me. I gave up and decided to get back into it later when I have more time to do more intensive Adwords research.