Critique My Photo Please: How To Get Useful Feedback On Your Photography

Ads by Google

photography feedbackWith digital photography, it’s easy to take photos, but it’s harder to take and make great images. Photography is an art form, not just a set of mechanical skills you apply to get great results. The Internet provides a wealth of resources for learning the art and skills of good photography. Besides taking photography courses and reading books and how-to articles, getting constructive feedback on your photos is another useful way to see what you’re doing well and what you could improve upon in shooting photos.

Many photo sharing sites include a way for viewers of your images to leave comments on your posts. If you post your photos on your blog you may also get useful feedback. But getting constructive critiques of your work requires some effort.


So the point of this article is to share a few useful groups and tips for getting constructive feedback on your images. These resources are limited to my experience and research on the photo sharing site, Flickr.com, so please share ones you have found useful.

Flickr.com Groups

By far the best place to get constructive feedback that I know of are in Flickr.com groups. When you become a member of Flickr and post lots of photos on a regular basis, you eventually start to build a large friend’s base that will typically provide positive feedback on images posted in your photostream. Typical comments include, “Nice shot,” “lovely capture,” “excellent,” “very well done.”

Ads by Google

photography feedback

While these comments are great – I sure appreciate getting them – they’re not constructive feedback. To have your photos critiqued on Flickr, you need to join and participate in several dedicated critical feedback groups. Here’s a few I know of:

Critique

The Flickr group, Critique, is one of the most popular and general critique groups I discovered. It has 7,000 members and over 8,000 discussion threads. After joining the group, you simply start a discussion thread with your selected photo and request feedback. Here’s an example.

feedback on photography

The type of photos and topics posted in discussion threads are varied. Members give feedback on lighting techniques, photo composition, macro shots, depth of field, exposure techniques, etc.  While some photos receive as many as ten comments, others may only receive one or two, but all feedback seems generally supportive.

Truly Constructive Criticism

This group has a little over 1,100 members and about the same amount of discussion threads. It’s open to both amateur and professional photographers.

feedback on photography

The rules for the group are simple: post one, critique one. When you provide good constructive feedback to members’ photos, you will gradually build a stronger, trusting friends base that will likewise provide you with the feedback you’re seeking.

feedback on photography

If you take a look at the photo pool of Truly Constructive Criticism you will see that members are not generally posting their best work. They’re posting photos for which they truly want real critiques, not images that have already received lots of variable feedback in their photostream.

Critique This!

This group has nearly 3,500 members, with 1,747 discussion threads. You don’t have to be a photo expert to join this group. It’s works like Truly Constructive, requiring you to provide as much critique as you receive.

image feedback

As with other groups, discussion threads typically start out like this: “I am a new member of Flickr and I’ve just started taking some portraits. What do you think of my shots? If you could give me advice or comments, it would help me a lot.”

Sometimes however, it’s useful to request specific feedback on a photo. You might ask members to critique the composition, lighting, or the post processing of photos. You should let them know what you were trying to achieve by taking the photo, and if they think you accomplished your goal.

The Portfolio Pro

Portfolio Pro Critique is a more advanced critique group with over 1,600 members and almost 800 discussion threads. The photos in this group typically are more advanced or professional than what exists in the other groups. However, the group is not limited to professional photographers.

image feedback

The posting and critiquing of photos is more structured for this group. When you post an image to the pool, members use a well designed Portfolio Pro Critique Template. The feedback on the template is converted to HTML code which can be pasted into the comment field of the photo being critiqued. The template itself helps generate very thoughtful critique.

Portfolio Pro also includes great weekly photo contests and challenges, and it’s also in the process of producing a book based on selections from its membership. If you’re serious about great photography, this group is well worth checking out.

Feedback Tips

  • When posting a photo for critique, it’s a good idea to ask for specific feedback, instead of asking, “What do you think?” Instead, you might ask about the framing of the shot, the use of external lighting, the post processing, or how well the subject was captured.
  • Likewise when critiquing a photo, be as specific as possible in your feedback. Start off with something positive to say about the image, and then critique how the image could have been shot better. Always try to provide suggestions for improvements.

photography feedback

  • You might consider posting two or more versions of a photo and asking members which one is the best and why.
  • Provide more critiques than you receive. Members are more trusting of you if they see you are an active member of the group, rather than someone who only shows up when you want feedback.

Do you find getting constructive feedback on your photos is helpful to you as a photographer? What websites or other resources do you use to get your photos critiqued? If you want to learn more about digital photography, check out these MUO articles, and also download my MUO Guide to Digital Photography.

Image credit: Shutterstock.com

Ads by Google

7 Comments - Write a Comment

Reply

B Sdf

Wonderful.

Share a website with you ,

put this url in google sirch

(http://www.aamall.us )

Believe you will love it.

We accept any form of payment

Reply

B Sdf

Wonderful.

Share a website with you ,

put this url in google sirch

( .aamall.us )

Believe you will love it.

We accept any form of payment

Reply

Slide Buddy

I wasnt aware that there are existing groups on Flickr, and an ongoing professional photography critiquing group. I’ll definitely visit soon, even if it’s not for the discussions, but just to stare at the gorgeous photographs.

Reply

Bakari

Thanks for the feedback, Slide. Yeah there are quite a few great Flickr groups like the ones above. You have spend a lot time on the site to find them though, or some searching.

Reply

Bakari

Totally agree. That’s why access to the net is something we need to always protect. It’s the freest form of information. Happy picture taking.

Reply

Donatella

Brilliant! You REALLY can find EVERYTHING on the net!

Bakari

Totally agree. That’s why access to the net is something we need to always protect. It’s the freest form of information. Happy picture taking.

Your comment