How to Build an Energy-Efficient Ethereum Mining Rig
Pinterest Stumbleupon Whatsapp
Advertisement

Energy-efficient What You Need For An Energy-Efficient Gaming PC What You Need For An Energy-Efficient Gaming PC Gaming computers are some of the most powerful consumer PCs on the market. Though beefy dual-processor workstations exist, they’re for work rather than play. People who buy a powerful computer for personal use usually do... Read More cryptocurrency mining saves you money, saves the planet, and can make you money. The trick is to maximize your hash rate per watt or reduce your system’s overall energy footprint. Here are the components and configuration settings needed to maximize your computer’s energy efficiency for mining the cryptocurrency Ethereum.

Ethereum Mining Precursor

There are two approaches to reducing power costs when mining Ethereum (or any cryptocurrency):

  1. You can reduce the total wattage consumption of the system.
  2. You can maximize the amount of cryptocurrency mined relative to its power consumption.

Both design styles end up looking very similar to one another. That’s because cryptocurrency mining focuses on two parts: the graphics card and the power supply. The rest of the computer can be little more than scrap heap pulls.

Let us begin with the most important component: the Graphics Processing Unit What Is the Difference Between An APU, A CPU And A GPU? What Is the Difference Between An APU, A CPU And A GPU? Over the last five or more years, there have been a number of different terms swirling around to describe computer hardware. Some of those terms include but aren’t limited to APU, CPU, and GPU. But... Read More (GPU).

Parts for Building Your Ultra-Efficient Miner

Energy-Efficient GPUs

The most energy efficient GPUs around come from Nvidia. Unfortunately, Nvidia GPUs aren’t quite as good at solving cryptographic hashes as AMD hardware. More or less, if you want energy efficiency (without paying a fortune for a 1070 or 1080), your only option is an AMD graphics card. The most energy efficient of these is the AMD Radeon RX 460 or RX 470 (or the pricier RX 560 and RX 570). The RX 470 pulls around 145 watts, with the recommended power supply for it producing around 350 total watts. The RX 460 on the other hand, uses a total of 75 watts. That makes it easier to deploy on single-card mining rigs.

AMD Radeon RX 460

The hash rate of the RX 460 is reported to be around 11 mega-hashes per second (MHS). With a “peak” wattage consumption of 75 watts, that translates to 0.147 MHS/W. The 470 produces a hash rate of around 25 MHS with a power consumption of around 120 watts for 0.208 MHS/W. Of the two, the 470 offers better efficiency per watt. But the 460 is easier to deploy on low-cost, low-end systems. And the 470 costs a great deal more on secondary markets. More or less, the 470 is running for well over $350 on eBay, whereas you can still get a 460 for around $100.

Note: The more RAM, the better the hash rate of the card. If you can get more RAM, do it.

The RX 460 Is Easier to Power

GPUs like the RX 470 require additional power from either a 6-pin or an 8-pin connector, supplied by your power supply unit (PSU).

Unlike the 470, the 460 draws so little power that it can operate entirely off the power supplied by the motherboard’s PCIe connector (which maxes out at around 75 watts). That means you don’t need an eight or 6-pin connector, so it can almost certainly operate off the energy supplied by what’s known as a picoPSU: a tiny, fanless, highly-efficient PSU.

Energy-Efficient Power Supply

The power supply determines how efficiently a computer pulls current from the wall socket. Unfortunately, the standard PSU converts from wall current (Alternating Current, also known as AC) to Direct Current (DC) at around 70 percent efficiency. That means 30 percent of the power pulled from the wall gets turned into waste heat. Fortunately, a variety of PSUs can convert at 80 percent and higher. When certified by the 80 Plus organization, a power supply unit receive an efficiency rating which varies depending on the load of the unit. The ratings vary between 80+, 80+ Bronze, 80+ Silver, 80+ Gold, 80+ Platinum, and 80+ Titanium. At the highest end of the spectrum, PSUs produce above 90 percent efficiency at all loads, but they tend to cost a fortune.

I prefer using what’s called a picoPSU. A picoPSU generally supplies power somewhere under 200 watts. It also tends to offer higher efficiencies than standard power supplies, at around 80 to 90 percent efficiency. If you’re using an RX 460, you can get away with a picoPSU. The model I recommend is the 160-XT. The XT includes a 4-pin CPU connector.

Mini-Box picoPSU-160-XT High Power 24 Pin Mini-ITX Power Supply Mini-Box picoPSU-160-XT High Power 24 Pin Mini-ITX Power Supply 160 watts 12V DC output Buy Now At Amazon $44.50

On the downside, you can’t just slap a picoPSU into a case without making modifications. For example, I had to run the DC power jack through my case’s three-pronged female port. On top of that, picoPSUs usually only support a single SATA-powered device. If your case places its storage drives in odd places, you might also need an extension cable.

PSU Case Modification

The Motherboard and Processor

There is only one requirement for the motherboard: it needs to support a full-size GPU. The processor doesn’t matter.

I would normally recommend using an Intel Atom motherboard. Unfortunately, no consumer-class Atom board offers full-sized PCIe x16 ports. Also, there’s some confusion regarding how much power the PCIe slot produces. According to its specifications, a PCIe x16 slot can deliver around 75 watts. That should be enough to handle the 75-watt draw of the 460, but some 460 manufacturers include an optional 6-pin connector — for added safety.

Mini ITX Motherboard

Fortunately, a handful of AMD motherboards include full PCIe slots and low-power processors. AMD released two different lines of processor that offered a winning combination of low power consumption, low cost, and a full PCIe slot: the AM1 platform Build a Leaner, Greener, Meaner HTPC with AMD's New AM1 Platform Build a Leaner, Greener, Meaner HTPC with AMD's New AM1 Platform This article covers the various components, with suggestions, for building an AM1-based media center or office productivity desktop. Read More and a series of motherboards with soldered-on processors. Of these, I prefer the ECS KBN-I/2100 — but these tend to be hard to find and overpriced. Fortunately, the AM1 platform provides similar low build cost and low power consumption. For example, you can find an AM1 dual-core Sempron processor for around $35. And the motherboard costs around $25 with Prime shipping.

Motherboard PCIe x16 slot

ECS Elitegroup KAM1-I (1.0) Socket AM1 motherboard ECS Elitegroup KAM1-I (1.0) Socket AM1 motherboard (WHQL) Windows Hardware Quality Labs Certified, Windows 7, 8, 10 Support. CE/FCC/Earp/Up Certification Buy Now At Amazon $31.00

The Rest of the Computer

The rest of the computer doesn’t matter much. In general, you want a case that can adequately cool either an RX 460 or RX 470 — but GPUs include their own cooling mechanism. The basic idea behind a case is that it shouldn’t impede the GPU’s ability to cool itself. Some people even choose to do open air builds. An extreme few daisy chain together multiple 470 GPUs on Ikea storage shelves!

Sample Build: Super Low-Energy Ethereum Miner

Here’s what my ideal build looks like:

  1. Motherboard + CPU: ECS KBN-I/2100 ($60 via eBay)
  2. GPU: XFX 4 GB RX 460 (Amazon)
  3. Case: RAIDMAX Elements ($30 via Newegg)
  4. PSU: 160XT picoPSU rated for 180 watts with adapter (Amazon)
  5. RAM: Crucial DDR3 1 x 2 GB DIMM (Amazon)
  6. SSD: DREVO X1 Series 60 GB SSD (Amazon)

Total wattage consumption: 100-120 watts
Estimated hash rate: 11 MHS/S
Hashes per watt: 11 MHS/100 W = 0.10 MHS/W

A slightly more expensive miner would differ in its PSU and GPU, but otherwise should look identical. Instead of using an RX 460, it might use an RX 470 (or even 480). Unfortunately, the prices of higher end cards has gone through the roof. I wouldn’t advise anything beefier than a 460 — just enough to get your feet wet mining crypto without costing a fortune in build costs and power.

Mini ITX Case

The SSD will ensure that this system is fast to boot and configure, and you could double the RAM by purchasing two 2 GB DIMMs instead of one. This would slightly increase the hash rate for very little additional cost.

Configuring Your Miner: Undervolting Your GPU

Like with CPUs, you can reduce the voltage supplied to the GPU and decrease the power consumed and waste heat produced. Whether or not there’s a trade-off depends on the silicon lottery. Most discrete graphics cards can undervolt How Undervolting Decreases Heat & Increases Battery Life How Undervolting Decreases Heat & Increases Battery Life Would you believe that many computers and smartphones can run cooler and consume less power? A trick exists, called undervolting, which can increase your CPU's efficiency with few drawbacks. If performed right, devices generally produce... Read More slightly without losing anything. However, a small number become unstable, even with a slight undervolt. You won’t know until you try.

If you have an AMD card, it works like this: install Radeon Settings. Run it, and then go to the Gaming Tab:

AMD Motherboard

Choose Global Settings:

AMD Motherboard

Choose the Wattman tab and scroll down until you reach the entry for Voltage Control (mV). From within this menu, you can reduce the voltage. However, keep in mind that your GPU draws a different voltage at each frequency. Personally, I use a 100 mV undervolt at each frequency. So, for STATE 1 through 7, I reduce the voltage by 100. The lowest it can go for the RX 480 is 800, so you’ll notice that the first two entries are at 800:

Mini ITX Case

If this makes your system unstable, Radeon Settings will automatically reset to the default voltage. There is virtually no risk of permanent instability. In the worst case scenario, you can simply remove your graphics card.

Should You Build an Energy-Efficient Ethereum Miner?

I’d say only as an experiment. The technology behind Ethereum, a big leap over Bitcoin’s underlying technology, may one day prove to be valuable. But cryptocurrency is so ridiculously speculative, it’s only worth taking a moderate risk on. I wouldn’t invest thousands into mining unless you really have thousands to spare, and make sure you’re aware of the risks What You Need to Know Before Investing in Cryptocurrencies What You Need to Know Before Investing in Cryptocurrencies Read More before spending any money.

Do you have an Ethereum mining rig? Has it made a return on its investment yet? Do you have any tips and tricks you can share? Let us know in the comments section below!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Mister M
    November 10, 2017 at 1:18 am

    Sorry for the multiple comments, I didn't think my comment had posted :/

  2. Mister M
    November 10, 2017 at 1:16 am

    Hi Kannon

    I have been following this article and built a machine using a Radeon RX460 (Gigabyte 4GB) on an Gigabyte GA-AM1M-S2H motherboard using a 460W PSU before trying a pico, and have installed all the relevant latest drivers.

    I am testing this with Minergate on Win 7 Pro 64, mining Monero and can only get 250 h/s.

    Could there be something I have missed?

    Thanks

    Mr M

    • Kannon Yamada
      November 10, 2017 at 1:25 am

      Sorry about the multiple comments. We need better thread tracking.

      So first of all, you're doing it right. By reusing old components, you keep your build costs low, which is the whole point of this exercise.

      Second, I can't think off the top of my head what might be going on. It's well established that the RX 460 can hit close to 11 MHS on a rig practically made from wet noodles. The hash you're getting is so ridiculously low, something is clearly off. And updating drivers is almost always the first thing to do.

      My best guess is that this is a Windows thing. WIndows is a complete disaster back when I tried to mine Ethereum on it. The Linux/Ubuntu set up is infinitely easier.

  3. Mister M
    November 10, 2017 at 1:11 am

    Hi Kannon

    I have just put an RX460 (Gigabyte Radeon 4GB) on a AM1 (Gigabyte GA-AM1M-S2H) board in an old Dell Case I have. I am currently using the 460W PSU, before trying a pico supply.

    I am using Minergate mining Monero to test the setup. I can't seem to get anything more than about 250 h/s.

    I've installed the latest Gigabyte drivers etc.

    Can't figure out what I'm doing wrong.

    Anything I might have missed?

    Thanks

    Mr M

  4. dinis
    October 31, 2017 at 12:01 am

    Hi. Great info.
    I have an old PC that doesn't have PCIe slots but has 4 USB's. I wonder what about if I use 4 PCI-E PCI Express X16 Extender and run the GPU's from the USB ports. would it work? like this, I would need a smaller investment, just to start playing with it.
    Another idea is to use my own laptop (toshiba R700), at night, using the same USB extenders but maybe the laptop power is not ready to supply the GPU. What is your opinion on this? In the case that it would be advisable to use laptop, would this interfere with my normal working or would it be advisable to let it work only when I am not using the laptop?
    Thanks in advance
    dinis

    • Kannon Yamada
      November 6, 2017 at 7:28 pm

      What kind of GPUs would you use? Do you have any examples? I've heard of external GPUs for workstation docks. In theory, it should work, since cryptomining generally runs off the GPU and doesn't use the CPU very much.

  5. RavMun
    October 13, 2017 at 9:00 am

    How much hash rate increase do you think you can get by getting a 2nd stick of 2gb ram in there? And is it better for power to use a single 4gb stick or 2 x 2gb sticks? What would be the increase in hash rate with say 8 or 16gb?
    Thanks!

    • Kannon Yamada
      October 16, 2017 at 5:23 pm

      IIRC, there is a very slight increase in hashing performance when the RAM is running in dual-channel mode or when more RAM is used. I'm not sure why this occurs. It could be due to sampling errors.

      All the mining machines that I've seen use 4GB of RAM. So it sounds as if RAM is not very important.

    • Kannon Yamada
      October 16, 2017 at 5:25 pm

      I should clarify, SYSTEM RAM is not very important. GPU VRAM is very important.

  6. Amit
    August 25, 2017 at 9:35 pm

    I am getting around 29 MH/s with my GTX 1070 and a peak power consumption of 150 W (that includes the entire Windows 10 PC)

    So thus turns out to be cheaper than AMD as you mention.

    • Kannon Yamada
      August 25, 2017 at 11:37 pm

      Thanks for letting me know Amit! The 1070 is such an amazing GPU. I wish it were horrible at crypto so I could afford one!

  7. Shep
    August 6, 2017 at 6:58 pm

    How much can you mine with a rig like this?
    Thank you so much for the great information Kannon!

    • Kannon Yamada
      August 6, 2017 at 9:34 pm

      It depends on the difficulty level. I'm not sure where Ethereum is right now, but a megahash rate of around 25 is what most people were getting with IIRC an RX 470 and they were profitably mining a few months ago. A hash rate of 11 MH/s isn't amazing, but it's almost half of an RX 470 (which sells for a ridiculous amount of money). You won't make any money unless Ethereum goes up in value vs your power costs. But using a build like this helps you keep the power cost and build costs lower than had you decided to get a 470 or 480.

  8. Daniel
    July 6, 2017 at 8:55 am

    Could I use this setup to install 2 GPUs RX 460 instead of one? I know that will drive the power cost up but Im wondering if the motherboard would take it. I don't mind an extra 100 watts for 11 MH/s of ETH

    • Kannon
      July 7, 2017 at 12:03 am

      You would need a different motherboard that's capable of supporting two different RX 460s. The software itself can run on two separate GPUs, so that's definitely not an issue. The issue is that dual GPU motherboards can cost quite a bit of money compared to single slot boards.

      The key is that the motherboard has to have two x16 slots (or two slots that can physically support an x16 card).

      • Daniel
        July 7, 2017 at 7:16 pm

        And what energy efficient motherboard + cpu would you recommend for that case? I want to buy 2 RX 460s and maybe bump the watts to 300 I don't mind as long as I can hash 22 MH/s on the same small machine.

        • Kannon Yamada
          July 9, 2017 at 1:35 am

          The problem is that motherboards with 2 x16 PCIe slots (either 2.0 or 3.0 should work) tend to cost quite a bit. Currently, I believe that people are buying older high end boards and using Celeron processors (which are the lowest tier for socketed processors) in order to get a board that's within an affordable price bracket. PCIe is an older socket, so in theory you should be able to go back pretty far and find something that works.

          Unfortunately, alt coin mining seems to have driven the prices on these boards up quite a bit. If you can find them at all. They're sold out most places:

          https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813157392

          The only sane option is the 460 at the moment, plus some weak hardware. I wouldn't even bother with using a dual GPU miner.

  9. Eddie G.
    June 28, 2017 at 6:42 am

    "Cryptocurrency"?....Hah! Stupid...money that isn't "real"......yeah...no I'll stick with The Real World thanks.

    • Ben
      July 16, 2017 at 5:43 am

      And you believe that our current monetary system is based in reality? How is a $100 bill printed on paper (not backed by gold or any other valuable tangible object) any more 'real' than any of these cryptocurrencies? You do realize that every dollar the U.S. government prints is printed with interest, right? As in, the Federal Reserve prints our government the $1 and charges us interest (whatever the Fed Rate is). Where do you think that interest comes from? It's simply made up. POOF, out of thin air. Where do you think any of our money comes from? What to you makes the digital representation of money you see when you log on to your bank account online
      and more real than what a crypto investor/miner sees when they open up their digital wallet?

      • kannon
        July 16, 2017 at 4:38 pm

        Thanks for the comment. I believe that Nixon ended convertibility into gold -- he did not end the relationship between the US's gold reserves and the dollar. The dollar is still backed by the tremendous amount of reserves held by the US government, which is why it's among the most stable currencies in the world.

        There is some debate over whether or not the US secretly sold off large parts of its reserves though -- but that's a separate discussion.

        Some however, argue that gold is a great way to back a currency. It's actually a pretty inefficient system since we still make a lot of products with gold.

        • Barry
          August 23, 2017 at 2:01 pm

          "The dollar is still backed by the tremendous amount of reserves held by the US government,"

          False. There is no relationship between the Gold held by the Treasury and the FRN.

        • Kannon Yamada
          August 23, 2017 at 2:46 pm

          The US dollar is backed by all of the nation's assets. And that includes its gold reserves. The US no longer fixes the value of the dollar to gold, which means it does not have to add gold to its reserves whenever it prints money.

  10. Simon
    June 27, 2017 at 7:24 pm

    OK, so I build the system per your sample build. Now what - What about the software? What software do I install (and configure) to do the mining?

    • Kannon Y
      June 27, 2017 at 7:43 pm
    • Rex
      June 27, 2017 at 11:09 pm

      Yes, Mr. Yamada, tell The Rest of the Story.
      I looked hard for the link to the Next Step: Mining Etherium for Dummies.
      Nada

    • Rex
      June 27, 2017 at 11:10 pm

      Yes, Mr. Yamada, tell us how to use this.
      I looked all over this page for a link to "Mining Etherium for beginners"

      Nada

    • Jimmy
      June 28, 2017 at 1:14 pm

      Lots of articles on how to do this. There's even a Linux distro specifically for Ether mining. EthOS. Not free but painless to set up. There's also free ones. C'mon guys, you can't have everything spoon fed to you.

      • Simon
        June 28, 2017 at 2:22 pm

        Really?? No one is asking to be "spoon fed.....", just for a few links and maybe some addition helpful advice from others in the community that have more experience in the subject.