Pinterest Stumbleupon Whatsapp
Ads by Google

boxee alternativeBoxee fans – it’s over. There may be more fun to have with the Boxee Box, but Boxee on the desktop isn’t coming back. It’s time to find something else if you have a computer hooked up to your television.

We should have seen it coming. There was an entire year between updates for desktop users, during which things continued to break. Certain shows stopped working, apps slowed down or broke entirely and new features appeared only on the Boxee Box. We put up with it. We loved Boxee, and wanted it to keep growing the way it did back in 2009 and 2010. We watched some shows in our browser, and used NaviX to fill in the gaps. Apps still worked, for the most part, and local playback was still decent.

During the summer of 2011 we were told we’d get an update in autumn. Months went by, autumn wound down; Boxee users grew impatient. Then, right around Christmas, Boxee released a new, bug-ridden version for Linux, Mac and Windows Boxee Launches A Huge Update To Their Desktop Client [News] Boxee Launches A Huge Update To Their Desktop Client [News] If you are a user of Boxee on your home computer, I have some good news and some bad news. I will start with the good news, after all, we all enjoy the happy stuff.... Read More only to also announce this was the final desktop version ever to be released: developers will from now on focus only on the Boxee Box and software for other set-top devices.

This makes sense. Boxee is a small company, and can’t spend money developing its program for every platform under the sun. Other than consumer devices Boxee doesn’t have much of a revenue stream, and millions of dollars in venture capital means Boxee needs to be profitable, soon.

So the desktop version’s decline was inevitable. Still, a total lack of updates leaves me feeling betrayed. I, and the large number of Boxee early adopters, sincerely felt like we were part of the team. We tested the software, provided feedback and helped promote the platform. Boxee kept releasing clever hacks to keep Hulu working for free, and promised they would always do that.

Those days are long gone, and it’s time for all desktop Boxee users to buy a box or find a new home.

Ads by Google

Story Of A Boxee User

I’m what you might call a Boxee fanboy. I’ve been using the program since its alpha release, and spent a great deal of time telling my friends and family they should be using it instead of cable. I wrote an excessively glowing review of Boxee’s beta Boxee Beta - The Best Media Center App for Your TV Boxee Beta - The Best Media Center App for Your TV Read More back in early 2010, and a series of follow-up articles after that. Boxee was the recreational program I used more than anything else.

If anyone should be excited about the current release of Boxee, it’s me. I’ve forgiven its shortcomings many times, looking back, because I always believed things would keep getting better.

boxee alternative

Not this time. The 1.5 release of Boxee for the desktop is buggy and frustrating. Most of the online shows I tried to watch didn’t work or didn’t launch in full screen. Support for Netflix, Hulu and more are dropped from the desktop version, meaning I need to turn to NaviX to watch many movies and shows. And a variety of apps simply don’t work any more.

I could say more, but it’s all been said in the Boxee forum, where users are openly discussing what program to switch to. None of these bugs would be a huge problem if updates were coming. The problem is they’re not. So it’s time to find something new.

Why Not Buy A Box?

boxee end-of-tv

So why don’t I support the program I love by buying a Boxee Box? Because I have a computer hooked up to my TV, which I use for a lot more than just media. I play games on it with a couple of joysticks, share files from it to my other computers and use it to test lots of different software.

Why not add a Boxee Box as well? Because I don’t want to take up more space with an unnecessary device. I’d be more than happy to pay for the privilege to use Boxee on my computer, and I think I’m not alone. At it’s best, Boxee worked better than anything out there. But I don’t want another device cluttering up my living room.

Boxee claims people like me are around for now, but won’t be for long: people are finding dedicated boxes to be better for the job. That may be the case. I get it. But if Boxee can’t support its desktop users anymore, how do I know they’ll keep supporting their box users? It’s not a completely fair question, but I can’t be the only person asking it.

What To Use Instead

boxee alternative

After seeing how awful the new Boxee is, last night I bit the bullet and installed XBMC. And I’m telling you: I should have done that months ago.I got my favorite plugins, Reddit TV and Navi X, working in no time. I found a plugin for streaming shows from CBS, NBC and all the major networks, and it works flawlessly in a way Boxee hasn’t for years.

Yes, it’s not as well organized. Yes, the interface is harder to use. But it works, and it’s actively being maintained. Check out XBMC or read our most recent review XBMC 10 "Dharma" - A Mature, Feature-Rich Cross-Platform Media Centre XBMC 10 "Dharma" - A Mature, Feature-Rich Cross-Platform Media Centre Read More .

A program I want to check out, but haven’t yet, is Plex Setup A Perfect Media Center With Plex [Mac & Windows] Setup A Perfect Media Center With Plex [Mac & Windows] Plex is widely regarded by many as being the best media player, manager and streaming application around - available for both Windows, Mac and even mobiles (though the mobile apps are not free). If you're... Read More . Since our last review Plex was updated to run on Windows natively, and I can’t wait to try it out. Feel free to let me know your thoughts about Plex below.

Conclusion

The Boxee team said it all: “We would not be where we are today without you. But we can’t stay here.”

I understand the sentiment, but will miss Boxee. You did web video well before you needed to make money, and standing up to big companies and hacking to keep stuff working is what made that great. Oh well, there are lots of new programs to try out with lots of clever programmers.

Can you think of something else I need to play with? Give me your thoughts in the comments below, because this recovering Boxee user needs ideas. I’ll be hanging out with you guys below.

  1. JP
    March 18, 2012 at 8:44 pm

    I installed plex because of this post and all I have to say is why didn't I start using plex a long time ago. It is much better than boxee and offers more applications and customizations.

  2. Gav Shaw
    March 1, 2012 at 7:34 am

    Boxee has been revived for the PC. While the app is no longer being supported by Team Boxee, some people have picked up where "Team Boxee" left off, and a new version of Boxee for the PC (v1.5) can be downloaded for free via Google Code's site :

    http://code.google.com/p/boxee-for-computers/downloads/detail?name=boxee-1.5.0.23596-2bcda77.exe&can=2&q=

    Note. Don't waste time contacting Team Boxee for Support as you will
    not get heard, but just refer to the following post for guidance if
    required http://forums.boxee.tv/showthread.php?t=52368

    • jhpot
      March 3, 2012 at 2:10 pm

      Interesting. I'm already using XBMC for pretty much everything, but I'll need to keep this in mind.

  3. Anonymous
    February 17, 2012 at 1:52 am

    BOXEE YOU SUCK IN PLAIN ENGLISH

  4. Kerry
    January 15, 2012 at 4:30 am

    I think MythTV is a good answer and it's free.  I agree with you on Boxee.  It is time to move on.

    • jhpot
      January 15, 2012 at 2:29 pm

      Myth is mostly a DVR, isn't it? I don't have cable, so it's not that useful for me...

  5. Jaypaq
    January 13, 2012 at 3:45 pm

    First off, Justin good job writing this, I just forwarded it
    to most people in my department. I tend to just skip thru these types of articles
    to get the just of it, but I read every word and could not agree more.

    I updated to Boxee 1.5 last night. I was super excited about
    the new new/improvement to the features and new UI (new compared to the version
    I was using .9 I believe), but then I started using it. WOW, it was buggy. I’m
    a professional QA software tester (for +12 years now) and it was really
    disappointing to upgrade to this 1.5 version. My former version was more stable
    it appears and without any patches, service packs or maintenance releases
    coming from Boxee, it was really disappointing. After using ver1.5 for 20
    minutes or so, I quickly got the vibe that they were sending a message with
    this version, as if to say go buy the hardware box now or this is what you’ll
    be stuck with. After being a loyal Boxee person for almost a year now, I’m
    jumping ship tonight, Plex is the first on my list as well I’ll check out XBMC
    as friends and family members are on that train. From a revenue standpoint, I
    think the Boxee folks missed an opportunity not supporting the PC version…some
    of us loyal folks might have paid rather than see it discontinued altogether,
    but if they have limited internal headcount and resources to support the
    hardware platform, I get that I suppose.

    Either way, thanks again for the article and good luck…I’ll
    post my Plex feedback and let you know how that goes J

    • jhpot
      January 13, 2012 at 4:22 pm

      1.5 is a nightmare. I'd be willing to pay for an up-to-date version, or at least I would have been. Now I'm realizing the alternatives aren't so bad.

  6. dostadawg
    January 13, 2012 at 5:54 am

    I like Boxee and can understand wanting to start making some cash but I think the Boxee Box is priced high for the market. If they cut the cost I would buy a couple of them..

    • jhpot
      January 13, 2012 at 4:20 pm

      The price for the device keeps going down, and their remote is awesome. But alas, it's not for me...

      • thenonhacker
        January 15, 2012 at 1:00 pm

        I got Boxee Box at a sale price at Dell Store. I highly recommend getting it, plus a 1 TB (or more) drive!

        The laptop plugged into the TV got freed up for others at home. :)

  7. Anthony Boone
    January 13, 2012 at 1:37 am

    PLEX is something I prefer over XBMC. Plex is ideal if you're storing your media in a different location. It offloads all the organizing, metadata, and art scraping to the Server App (plus other stuff like MyPlex video queues, and plugin storage), while the client is more or less a pretty front-end. With this setup, it is lightening fast on my network. Also, you can watch all of your media outside of your network, due to the client/server nature of PLEX.

    • jhpot
      January 13, 2012 at 4:20 pm

      I'm looking forward to playing with this...

  8. Boonejr89
    January 12, 2012 at 11:11 pm

    I'm interested to know if SOPA has played any part in there decision to discontinue the free desktop version and go with just selling the boxee box itself.I'm also curious if SOPA does in fact go into effect how entertainment software like boxee, xbmc, plex and others will be affected. Hmmm maybe a future article on that???

    • jhpot
      January 13, 2012 at 4:20 pm

      Not really. Boxee needs partnerships with media companies in order to be profitable. For example: they want a cut of Hulu Plus subscriptions for Boxee Box users.  This is less about law than it is about money.

  9. Phil Fot
    January 12, 2012 at 7:16 pm

    There's also NeurosTV from Neuros Technology. It's a web-based package that they use to drive their Neuros LINK box. You can access NeurosTV from any browser.

    • jhpot
      January 13, 2012 at 4:19 pm

      That's interesting. I've added it to my "check-out" list!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *