BestInClass Helps You To Find The Best Digital Camera

Mar. 24th, 2009 By Jim Henderson

There’s nothing quite like finding an actual, honest, unbiased opinion, especially in the technology arena.

If you could get some sort of logic applied to the opinions as well, the value would go through the roof. That’s the whole basis of BestInClass.

Find a group of experts who actually know what they are talking about, assemble their opinions, tabulate the answers, and present them in a way that actually helps you to make decisions. For free.

There’s a catch, right? Well, aside from some harmless Google ads, it seems not. Come and take a look with me.

When you visit the site you’re presented with a basic options page:

bic-ticked

Click the View Recommendations button.

An algorithm, claimed to have taken two years to develop, presents you with some recommendations, in order of preference. You’re either going to love or hate this. It’s something to do with being told by a computer what to do.

In any case, for the settings above, the recommendation was fairly clear.

bic-g10-550

Okay, now I’m a Canon guy, so I’d be fine with this, but if I had some reason to dislike the first option there are a string of three others below, including another Canon and two Panasonics.

So, a couple of things. Why should I trust the recommendations?

BestInClass has a group of experts to evaluate the cameras and provide a number of different opinions, and there is no sales bias. Doubtless there is some user bias, but that’s what recommendations are all about.

So, what if your requirements are more complex than can be captured in those initial questions?

Easy. Answer some more. On the left side of the results page is a huge list of tick boxes to narrow your choices.

bic-brandsFor instance, the first box allows you to choose the brands of cameras you’re interested in.

The default is to search all of the available brands, but you can restrict the search to whichever brands you prefer.

Clicking the More button adds Fuji, Casio, Kodak, Leica, Olympus and Pentax to the list.

bic-priceBy the way, there’s no update button here. The list just changes when you release the slider.

Simple, right? Some options use a combination of live sliders and update buttons. Just have a play.

bic-brandupdateClicking on a particular brand presents you with an Update button. Clicking that will present you with a new list of recommendations.

Time for a confession. A couple of cameras back I had the option of walking in and picking up a silver Panasonic camera, or waiting a week for the same model in black. I waited, so it would be hypocritical for me to make fun of the Color tickboxes, though I’m tempted. Pink?

Okay, so you have a resulting list of recommendations. Let’s dig into that a little more, by taking a look at the leader.

A summary about the camera is presented here, but if you need more detail, clicking on the link here, or the large image to the right, will take you to a detailed page for the recommendation by that particular expert.

You’ll see that the camera you were looking at is not necessarily in the number one spot on the Expert Recommendation page, because now we are only looking at the opinions of a single expert.

bic-procon

This page includes in-depth analysis, and comparisons. Pros and cons of the recommended camera are supplied (in this case the Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX3, which is, you must admit, a hell of a mouthful for a little camera).

bic-compare

Also included is a comparison chart for the recommendations.

bic-linksBack on the initial recommendation page there are also links to opinions from other websites and customers, along with Amazon purchase links, and price comparisons. In all, a huge amount of valuable information.

So, is it perfect?

No, not yet. There seem to be some holes in the coverage, especially where new or elderly cameras are concerned. Don’t get me started on the fact that it’s all in US dollars, as well.

But it’s most helpful if you’re in the market. Now if only I could work out a way to get a good price for my EOS 30D.

You can also get some good comparison action from some of the competition too. Check out TestFreaks for a broader product base than just cameras, or allCamReviews for a custom Google search for cameras. Kallow provides for a rather, well, shallow look, specialising in single recommendations for each category.

Have a play, and let me know how you do. Are there some other sites you would use for this purpose?  Let me know in the comments.

(By) Jim's a working stiff in IT during the day, and has been so since about DOS 3.0, but tries to spend the magic hours out with a camera. He lives in New Zealand.

Enjoyed the article? Subscribe to MakeUseOf to get daily updates on new cool websites and programs in your email for free. You'll also get free printable cheat sheets to your favorite programs

Your Email:

Add MakeUseOf to:



8 Comments Add Comment
2009-03-24 18:36:56
Maleman

One important feature never seems to be addressed. That is the “recovery” time. You take a photo using the flash and then you wait… and wait… for the camera to reset for the next picture. By the time the camera is ready again, the object of the next photo (small child, animal, moving vehicle) is nowhere to be seen. Why can’t the recovery time be listed along with other features. This one lack is holding me back from splashing the cash for another camera. I made one mistake already.

2009-03-25 12:10:43

This is a good point. We publish the “Flash Recovery Time” on our Product Details page for most of our recommended cameras. This is the time for the flash to recharge after a full power discharge.

2009-03-24 18:42:33
Dylan

There’s no such thing as an unbiased opinion.

2009-03-25 00:00:41
Jim

True enough. Perhaps ‘less biased’ would be a better phrase.

2009-03-25 07:01:34
Daniel

… isn’t this the third BestInClass recommendation here this week???

2009-03-25 11:53:07

I like BestInClass.com. For a recommendations site, they rock. Not to mention that the guys who did it were the founders of pogo.com and former Stanford eggheads. lol.

2009-03-25 13:14:43
Jim

Hi Daniel.

I don’t think so. It’s in our brief directory listings from last week, and this is the first full post on the site.

Cheers

2009-03-25 15:08:29

Thanks for the great article. Please let us know if you have any additional comments or feedback on the site! We’ve worked hard to make it a useful resource.

Reply

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.