Are Any Android Tablets As Good As The iPad?

Ads by Google

android tablet vs ipadThe latest web traffic statistics show that 78% of all web surfers using a tablet after the holiday season were on an iPad. Though its dominance is slowly dwindling, Apple’s device remains on the throne.

You may wonder – why? Is the iPad all that, or have better Android devices been ignored because of Apple’s famously effective marketing? That’s a difficult and controversial question, but not impossible to answer.

Why Does The iPad Dominate?

android tablet vs ipad

Before looking at rivals we should first clarify why Apple’s iPad has done so well. Some fanatics from the Android camp cling to the belief that Apple’s products sell to brainwashed yuppies that don’t know any better. That’s simply not the case. There are several reasons for the iPad’s dominance.

Display Quality

The iPad offered much higher display quality than most competitors even before Retina was revealed. After Retina, competitors have struggled to provide higher pixel density. Color accuracy, gamut and black levels are also excellent on Apple’s tablet.

Speed

Apple is one of only two companies that go to the trouble of designing processors in-house (the other is Samsung). Performance is the beneficiary. Benchmarks have consistently shown the iPad to be among the quickest tablets in the world. GPU performance is particularly good – no other tablet on the market can rival it.

Ads by Google

Battery Life

Despite bumps in speed, Apple has remained focused on battery life. It’s the reason why the third-generation iPad is thicker than the second. Battery life benchmarks reveal that all models of iPad score better than average.

The App Store

When Google released Android for tablets it did not encourage developers to make tablet-specific apps. Instead it encouraged apps that could be used on any device. Apple took a different approach and asked developers to focus on apps built for tablets only. This is why there are many excellent iPad apps but few excellent Android tablet apps.

In summary, Apple’s iPad has everything a consumer might want. It is attractive and quick yet doesn’t compromise on endurance. These features have made it possible for Apple to remain dominant despite the iPad’s relatively high price.

What about the iPad Mini? It is less impressive than the larger model in almost every way, yet the same praise applies when compared to other 7-inch tablets. The Mini is quick and has excellent battery life.

Enter The Challengers

Now that the iPad’s benefits are explained let’s have a look at potential challengers. There are just three tablets that are can legitimately stand up to Cupertino’s champion. They are the Google Nexus 10, ASUS Transformer Pad Infinity and Kindle Fire HD 8.9.

Google Nexus 10

android vs ipad tablet

The Nexus 7 is a nice tablet. I know this because I own one. It is small, however, which means it will always be a budget alternative. Google’s Nexus 10 is a true challenger to the iPad and the best Android tablet on the market today. It beats the iPad in some benchmarks, slightly exceeds it in display resolution and does so at a price of just $399.

Yet there are a few problems. While Android 4.2 is a great operating system, it can’t get away from Android’s poor tablet app selection. Battery life is a bit short of the iPad, though still good enough for many users. And storage is limited because a 32GB model is the largest sold and there is no microSD slot.

Google seems to be selling a fair number of Nexus 10 tablets, as the model is constantly sold out at the Google Play store. Yet I have a hard time recommending it over the iPad. A $100 discount isn’t enough to compensate for its problems.

ASUS Transformer Pad Infinity TF700

android vs ipad tablet

ASUS surprised everyone when it released the Transformer, a great tablet that could also be used as a miniature laptop. Since then the company has refined the concept and split the line into several different models. The Infinity is the best and most expensive among them.

With that said, however, ASUS hasn’t been able to keep up with the pace of Apple’s innovation. The Infinity isn’t as quick as the current iPad and can’t match its display quality. Battery life is inferior without the keyboard dock, which adds endurance at the cost of bulk.

ASUS technically has a price advantage because it offers 32GB of storage at $499.99, while the iPad offers 16GB for the same money. Yet that’s only an advantage to buyers who desire a lot of storage. Users will be disappointed by the Infinity’s MSRP.

The wild car is the keyboard dock, which is much better than anything compatible with the iPad. But it’s also an extra $139.99. That’s a lot of money for a peripheral, yet there’s no reason to buy the Infinity without one. The iPad is a superior tablet.

Kindle Fire HD 8.9

android tablet vs ipad

Amazon rapidly matured its lineup of tablets after the release of the original Kindle Fire, which I thought disappointing. The Kindle Fire HD 8.9 is the current flagship. A glance at the specifications quickly reveals that it is in every way inferior to the iPad. These disadvantages are excusable, however, because pricing starts at $299 for a 16GB model.

Unfortunately the Kindle Fire HD makes other mistakes. Though it runs Android, it uses a heavily modified version built to work hand-in-hand with Amazon’s app store and media content. Users won’t gain all the benefits from new versions of Android and the respectable selection of default apps, like the Chrome browser, are replaced with inferior alternatives Amazon has developed in-house. I can’t possibly express how much I hate the direction Amazon has taken with this tablet. Why did they replace the default Android browser with one that works less well? What were they thinking?

The price on this tablet makes the iPad Mini a legitimate a competitor, and it is better in almost every way. Only die-hard Amazon fans (do such people exist?) should go with the Kindle.

Conclusion

Having reviewed the options, the reason for Apple’s continued dominance in the tablet market seems clear – it makes the best product. It also makes the most expensive product, but that doesn’t seem to deter consumers, who continue to buy the iPad in droves.

Does that mean the Android tablets are invalid? Of course not. Android is different from iOS, and some users will absolutely want an Android tablet not because of superior hardware but instead because it runs Android – full stop. As the more open platform, users can tweak Android in ways that the iPad makes impossible.

But the people who desire Android for its openness probably don’t need my advice. They already have an Android device and already are experimenting with its possibilities. Apple’s iPad remains the better choice for most buyers.

Join live MakeUseOf Groups on Grouvi App Join live Groups on Grouvi
Best Android Apps
Best Android Apps
144 Members
Android Rooting and ROMs
Android Rooting and ROMs
93 Members
Android OS Tips
Android OS Tips
80 Members
Smartphone Photography
Smartphone Photography
54 Members
Awesome iPhone Apps
Awesome iPhone Apps
53 Members
Best Android Phones
Best Android Phones
50 Members
Best Android Games
Best Android Games
49 Members
Best Android Tablets
Best Android Tablets
31 Members
Android Rumors and News
Android Rumors and News
28 Members
Jailbreaking iOS
Jailbreaking iOS
22 Members
Ads by Google
Comments (30)
  • hotdoge3

    if you live in new zealand or Australia for get iPad high price mac tax

  • John

    The elephant in the room for Android is the lack diverse application software and the lack of critical mass from the commercial software development community. Everyone makes comparisons based on hardware, screen size, and ability to tweak the OS and get under the hood so to speak. None of these speak to the question of “What can I do with it?”

    If I all I did was surf the web, buy stuff on Amazon or read a eBook, then any tablet would do with Kindle being the front runner. But this is not the case for the majority consumers (78% apparently) and it not because of “Apple marketing”. The reason the iPad is at the top of the hill is because it offers more quality software (Games, Utilities… just about everything) which makes it function more like a laptop then web device. This is really the argument of Betamax vs VHS all over again. From a consumer perspective Betamax had its supporters. But they just couldn’t get the content.

    I can hear the grumblings already from people that do not like comparison. I will tell you this as a software developer, I can speak to the many reason why this is the case and why it is not as attractive make software for Andriod.

    1.) Developers have an incentive to write iOS apps – Marketing data shows Apple users BUY software – Android users seldom do.

    2.) It is very costly to write and test an application across all version flavors of Andriod out there. Samsung being the worst offender here by creating its own tweeks to Andriod and making the task of write once run everywhere impossible. ( In my opinion this is why google introduced the Nexus…. to get Samsung to stop polluting the OS and row the boat in the same direction Google wants) Hey I bough a Samsung infuse phone with the “Samdriod” version of Andriod installed on it and I was very disappointed with never being able to upgrade to newer versions of android and I certainly didn’t like the security holes the introduced with their changes anyway….

    Until Google can offer software developers as good as a platform as iOS for monetizing these apps this trend will not change. Hell even the Surface is better from that perspective.

  • Walter Askew

    Thanks for the review. I have been looking at tablets for awhile now, at least now I only need to look nat three.

    Walter

  • Dave Hilling II

    I am a big Android fan, but I use both for very different purposes. As a musician, I love the real-time sound processing capabilities of the iPad with the iRig adapter for my guitar. It’s actually saved me money over buying stompboxes that tend to run about $50-$100 apiece. I do everything else with my Androids because of their customization. Other than sound processing, the playing field is pretty level.

  • Vipul Jain

    Well the development behing Nexus 10 is enough is enough to make it go leaps ahead of the iPad.
    Also gone are those days when the generic statement “Android lags” applies :p
    So IMO Nexus 10 > iPad > Others.

Load 10 more
Affiliate Disclamer

This review may contain affiliate links, which pays us a small compensation if you do decide to make a purchase based on our recommendation. Our judgement is in no way biased, and our recommendations are always based on the merits of the items.

For more details, please read our disclosure.
Affiliate Disclamer

This review may contain affiliate links, which pays us a small compensation if you do decide to make a purchase based on our recommendation. Our judgement is in no way biased, and our recommendations are always based on the merits of the items.

For more details, please read our disclosure.