Is Your Antivirus Tracking You? You’d Be Surprised At What It Sends

Your antivirus software is watching you. A recent study shows that popular antivirus applications like Avast assign your computer a unique identifier and send a list of all web addresses you visit to the manufacturer. If the antivirus finds a suspicious document, it will send the document to the antivirus company. Yes, your antivirus company might have a list of web pages you’ve visited along with your sensitive personal documents!

AV-Comparatives’ Data Transmission Report

We’re getting this information from AV-Comparative’s Data transmission in Internet security products report, released on May 8, 2014. AV-Comparatives is an antivirus testing and comparison organization.

The study was performed by analyzing antivirus products running in a virtual machine to see what they sent to the antivirus company, reading each antivirus product’s end user license agreement (EULA), and sending a detailed questionnaire to each antivirus company so they could explain what their products do.

The study says “We gave higher weighting to our own measurements and the EULA (as we understand it) than to the replies to our questionnaire.” In other words, some antivirus companies responded with incorrect answers that contradicted what their products actually did!

We encourage you to check the study and consult the table on page 3 for yourself. You’ll be able to see exactly what your current antivirus product does. The study includes antivirus products by AhnLab, Avast, AVG, AVIRA, Bitdefender, BullGuard, Emsisoft, eScan, ESET, Fortinet, F-Secure, G DATA, Kaspersky Lab, McAfee, Microsoft, Panda, Sophos, Symantec, Trend Micro, Vipre, and Webroot.

av comparatives questions   Is Your Antivirus Tracking You? Youd Be Surprised At What It Sends

A Unique Identifier And Web Addresses You Visit

All of the antivirus products in question — aside from products by eScan and Fortinet — assign your system a unique identification number and transmit this number.

Many products also transmit a list of visited URLs, or web addresses — both malicious and non-malicious ones. All of the products aside from AhnLab, Emsisoft, and Vipre transmit these URLs to the company. It’s unclear which types of addresses each product transmits. Some products may only transmit a malicious address you find to the company, while some products may transmit all addresses you visit to the company. Tied to a unique identifier, this means an antivirus company could have access to your browsing history.

Some products also transmit your computer’s name, local IP address, language, running processes, and Windows user name to the antivirus company.

avast security statistics4   Is Your Antivirus Tracking You? Youd Be Surprised At What It Sends

Non-Executable Files, Including Documents

When an antivirus finds a “suspicious” file, it wants to send that file to the antivirus manufacturer so it can be examined for malware. The antivirus company can analyze the file and produce a virus definition to defend against the malware. This doesn’t just apply to executable files. Your antivirus may also send your personal documents to the antivirus company. For example, if you have a business document in Word format and the antivirus thinks the document is suspicious, it may send that document to the antivirus company. This means your antivirus company may be getting its hands on your sensitive documents.

Avast, Fortinet, Kaspersky Lab, Symantec, and Vipre all will transmit documents and other non-executable files. AVG, ESET, McAfee, Microsoft, Sophos, Trend Micro, and Webroot all won’t tell us if they transmit documents. It’s probably best to assume these products transmit documents, too. AVG, McAfee, Trend Micro, and Webroot won’t even allow you to opt out of sending these non-executable files.

windows defender maps   Is Your Antivirus Tracking You? Youd Be Surprised At What It Sends

Why All the Data Collection?

Antivirus companies want all the data they can get. However, we users don’t have an easy way of knowing and choosing what types of data we share with the antivirus company. The idea that the web pages we visit and our personal documents could be getting sent in the background is scary. We didn’t even think of this and didn’t have the option to make an informed decision. If this data is sent unencrypted, it’s also possible for people on the same local network — or intelligence agencies like the NSA tapping the internet backbone — to capture this information.

According to the study, antivirus companies at least say they aren’t linking this information together to track you:

“Vendors tell us that the data gathered and transmitted by each product does not go to a single collection centre; rather, specific elements are transmitted separately to different isolated end points, without any connection between them. Thus e.g. licence-management data is sent separately from product-usage statistics. They say that as there is no connection between these systems, the data collected by one cannot be linked with the data collected by another. Consequently the privacy of the user should be safeguarded. “

avast community   Is Your Antivirus Tracking You? Youd Be Surprised At What It Sends

The Most Privacy-Conscious Antiviruses

AhnLab sends the least amount of data according to this test. It won’t send URLs you visit, personal documents, or even executable files and other personal information to the antivirus company. It will transmit information about the antivirus product, a unique identifier for your computer, your operating system version, and hashes of files. A hash will let the antivirus company detect whether the file matches another file they know about, but it won’t actually let them view any of the contents.

Emsisoft also comes out looking good. They send a bit more information when you encounter malicious files — for example, they’ll send suspicious executable files to the antivirus company — but they’ll never send a list of websites you visit or your documents over the Internet

Both of these products are paid antivirus products. They’re the only antiviruses in the study that don’t send the most sensitive types of data to an antivirus company.

emsisoft anti malware trial   Is Your Antivirus Tracking You? Youd Be Surprised At What It Sends

There’s no one free antivirus product that stands out from all the others in offering the best privacy features. Your best bet is consulting the table for more information when choosing an antivirus product. Along with checking antivirus test results, this information can help you make an informed decision.

Image Credit: Cristiano Betta on Flickr

34 Comments - Write a Comment

0 votes
Reply

Adrian

Wow…this is scary. I’m gonna give Emsisoft a try. Thanks for the article.

1 votes
Reply

Mega

I use no Antivirus on my PC, since I started using Windows 7.

0 votes

dragonmouth

Then Redmond is tracking you. :-)

0 votes
Reply

Wasp S

Ive got a laptop i decided to use for a test. I scan once weekly with MBAM to see if its clean i use the extra tool like the root kit scanner too, other than that it has had no Anti-Virus installed since 2011. The only time it got an infection was after plugging an external hard drive in that had made the rounds in India. I think with sensible browsing , common sense with regard to email attachments and making sure security patches are applied straight away it seems to me alot of these products are making money for nothing.
I think it funny we are trying to protect ourselves from the hackers but who is protecting us from the companies we freely invite into our devices to do the protecting?

0 votes

SGKris

I totally agree with you and do exactly what you have said – Regular MBAM sacanning besides using firefox with NoScript and AdBlaock addons and no auto image loading as default in emails while using Windows. I too got infected once by plugging a USB falsh drive, but recovered without any problem by restoring a drive image. . I mostly use Linux for web surfing.

Sensible browsing and common sense constiture the best defense.

0 votes
Reply

Tony

I am uninstalling aVast now. It is terrible !

0 votes
Reply

Bud

Interesting article, but the Orwellian doom is 30 years late and will be, until Armageddon and these bastards are sent to Hell !!!!!!!!!!!

0 votes
Reply

T

Software with source code that isn’t available for inspection is likley to have hidden undesirable “features”.

0 votes
Reply

Michael Dowling

I’m using the free version of Avast!,along with Sandboxie.I have be tempted to ditch my antivirus program,as I always run my browser and email client sandboxed.

0 votes
Reply

Barry

My anti-virus is names Linux.
It does exactly what I tell it to.

0 votes

Derek

Puppy Linux for me. Great OS, and it’s never yet melted to a virus.

0 votes
Reply

Jerick

This definitely bothers me… But what could be the course of action? I don’t plan to change my AV

Considering most of them actually traces the “website”, does that mean they’re sent what is written on it as well? Then I’m scared for life :(

Thanks for this!

0 votes
Reply

Noer W

Iiii….ngeri dach, ga pake AV aja kalee

0 votes
Reply

Josemon M

Yea, that’s correct ..privacy is the top factor..That increases the priority of the migration to opensource operating systems like Linux for office works

0 votes
Reply

justme

Also from the report:

“We asked whether special updates are delivered to users with specific IDs. This could theoretically allow authorities with a suitable court order to monitor e.g. specific terror suspects without the monitoring software being detected by the antivirus product. All updates would however be supplied to all other users, ensuring that their PCs were still fully protected. Most of the vendors responded that they do not do this, although a few (mostly from the USA and UK) did not reply to this question. ”

Anglo AV companies: we protect against root-kits, etc . . . . . unless it’s government root-kits, then we’ll look the other way.

0 votes
Reply

LinuxMage

I am a Linux User…No such worries …I suppose people could encrypt their Document Folder and prevent their data from being compromised or save all sensitive files to a flash drive either way I am happy that this is at least one less headache I have to be concerned about.

1 votes
Reply

Renard Moreau

[ Smiles ] My goodness! I never thought that my own antivirus would be performing data mining.

Thank you for brining this to my attention!

0 votes
Reply

CJ Cotter

You wrote, “The idea that the web pages we visit and our personal documents could be getting sent in the background is scary. We didn’t even think of this…….” Are you serious? That’s very naïve…..like a clueless sheep walking through a field of wolves. I use McAfee Site Advisor. I have never needed a study to tell me that when McAfee throws a warning flag on my screen, their servers know WHERE I am, and WHO (me) has just triggered their tripwire. (This is true even when I always UNcheck the “participate” option.)

C’mon people, WAKE UP!

0 votes
Reply

paul.b

I know for a fact that AVG Antivirus (different than Avast, but also very popular) has a team team that analyzes the data their antivirus collects from their customers (what websites they visit, what software they have on their computer) in order to use it for marketing purposes. They justify that it’s ok for them to do it since Google does it too. Go figure.

0 votes

Joses L

They do that? Can I have a link please? I would like to read deeper into that…

0 votes

Vananovion

In AVG it is possible to disable this from Advanced Settings -> Privacy Preferences. If you are performing a new installation, it is possible to opt-out at the of setup wizard.

0 votes
Reply

MadAsAWetOldChicken

I use SandBoxie, Mozilla and never had virus infection. I am uninstalling AVG from wife’s lappy soon as I get home tonight. To hell with these corporations.

0 votes
Reply

OnClogs

In Sophos it is a simple setting whether or not you want samples of suspect files, which can be both executables and documents containing scripts (Office, PDF, etc) sent to the SophosLabs.

0 votes

Guy M

Assuming the setting actually does anything, or just makes you feel better about it.

0 votes
Reply

Vananovion

“AVG, McAfee, Trend Micro, and Webroot won’t even allow you to opt out of sending these non-executable files.”

This is not true at least for AVG. It is possible to opt-out either at the end of the installation or through Advanced Settings -> Privacy Preferences.

0 votes
Reply

ShorePatrol

I do not see that you ran any tests for Norton which comes bundled, if you want it, with Comcast. I can only assume that they are at least as FUBAR as all the rest. Anyone know how they operate?

0 votes
Reply

Anonymous

why am i not surprised…

0 votes
Reply

sobic

intersting.
btw, EFF Privacy Badger sez these sites are tracking us on YOUR page:
http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/antivirus-tracking-youd-surprised-sends/
Detected trackers from these sites:

main. makeuseoflimited….
www. google. com
0.gravatar. com
apis.google. com
platform.twitter. com
themes. googleuserconte…
accounts.google. com
ssl.gstatic. com
http://www.youtube. com
oauth. googleuserconten…
t0.gstatic. com
t1.gstatic. com
t3.gstatic. com
cdn.syndication. twimg….
s.ytimg. com
http://www.gstatic. com
fbstatic-a. akamaihd. ne

cute, no? (No.)

0 votes

G Farkas

Excellent comment!!

0 votes
Reply

rric117

Are European users better or worse with antivirus software? I want to know how to stop this intrusion!!!
rricmmanw@yandex.com

0 votes
Reply

dave

sending visited urls to home base…!!!?
i am so fv<ked off about this i have uninstalled AVG who the fv<k do these companies think they are?
i looked at eset and they do it too!! i thought they were good!

0 votes
Reply

klb3317

Using Emsisoft already, such a relief.

0 votes
Reply

Chiron

Well, I guess that sooner or later they’ll end up installing a webcam in every toilet (with the full blessing of Governments, Authorities, Polices, Secret Services and Holy Inquisition, of course) presumably quoting the old refrain “the one who has nothing to conceal has nothing to fear”.
In the world I was born in, reading other people’s mail without their explicit consent was considered a felony and a court order was needed to search one’s private documents, but that’s history now.

I was sent here by Emsisoft, which suggests that they are more correct than the others, thus I shall switch to their software in no time.
Yet the best protection is still to say good bye to the social media, unplug the internet cable and work stand-alone on a freshly installed OS, the way we used to do a few decades ago. Pretty sad, isn’t it?

0 votes
Reply

faruque

Start using linux everyone ……….

http://www.ubuntu.com/

Your comment