Does an Ubuntu Live CD provide more security in online financial transactions?
Question by Partha Sarathy /

By using Live CD like Ubuntu on my Windows desktop, do I have more security in my online financial transactions?

Browse other questions & answers in the category , ; tagged , , , .
Join live MakeUseOf Groups on Grouvi App Join live Groups on Grouvi
374 Members
Windows Troubleshooting
Windows Troubleshooting
279 Members
Best Windows Software
Best Windows Software
267 Members
Online Security Tips
Online Security Tips
251 Members
Master the Linux Command Line
Master the Linux Command Line
214 Members
Linux for New Switchers
Linux for New Switchers
165 Members
Best Linux Apps
Best Linux Apps
135 Members
New Security Breaches
New Security Breaches
134 Members
Linux Distros Talk
Linux Distros Talk
115 Members
Mac OS X & Software
Mac OS X & Software
73 Members

Comments for this Question are closed.

Answers (18)
  • dragonmouth

    As Freud Iomc stated, the problem is the security of the transmission and of the server on the other end. Once the financial data leaves your computer, no matter how secure that is, you have NO control over the security of that data.

    • Banker

      It’s one half less of the What-if problems that you have to worry about. Now, if only the online banks can provide a last login information of where and when every time you log in.

  • Abba Jee

    any Live OS is more secure than any windows OS no matter what AV or firewall installed in it for financial transactions , I’ve seen so many banks now adays using live OS for transactions

  • Douglas Mutay

    Yes but only if your windows is already infected.

  • Ramon Fletcher

    Probably best to try booting from that CD and shutting down when finished however you should just get rid of windows and use ubuntu. Depending on your location and as long as your being responsible if your money is stolen then it is the banks responsibility to replace it

  • Dino Pearsons

    Yes and no. While running a Live CD natively on the machine (not inside a Virtual Machine) will certainly make sure that you don’t have any malicious processes running in the background, it still won’t guarantee your safety.

    As with most things, the most important part of safety with these kinds of transactions is user diligence.

    If you keep your system clean, run a firewall and a decent anti-virus program, and pay attention to what you’re doing, I honestly don’t see why you should bother with running Linux from a Live CD.

  • Adrian Rea

    On the whole it can be considered as safe as the day that CD version was launched as it will not have been updated with any security fixes since then. So unless you hear of a specific vulnerability you would be fine to use a LiveCD. If you are concerned your windows install is compromised, think about backing up vital files and reinstalling.

  • Sunil Joseph

    Using live CD would be a bit safer since it is a clean environment, but if you run it within Windows, then any keylogger already installed in Windows will be able to pick up the keystrokes even though it wont be able to say which page you were on. You might want to read this if you are interested in keeping your computer safe.

  • vivek yadav

    no…it does not make any difference

  • ha14

    Linux Live CD like Ubuntu is read-only media, running entirely in RAM, will be much more secure than Windows. shut down and reboot will be only thing that stop you to use live cd.

    • Muz RC

      I agree, live cd means you run it in virtual environment so thats means anything you do is on cloud, once reboot its leave no trace behind.

  • Lisa Santika Onggrid

    Hypothetically yes, since you’d have a clean environment without any malware, and no data trace could be found once you eject the CD. This can be useful especially if you’re doing your transaction with another machine that’s not your own (assuming we always set our own machine to be fully protected) or in public places.

    That in mind, it’s not a good idea dealing with such important activity using public network, as someone could ‘sniff’ you, whatever OS you’re using.

    Justin is right. With good setup, Windows is okay.

Load 10 more
New comment

Please login to avoid entering captcha

Log In