Jul242012

Should I buy an Asus Transformer or the Toshiba Portege?

Denny Lawton asks:

Could you advise on best/appropriate device for my needs? I currently have a HP Pavillion DV6.

Priority: Photos, Office, Communication, Portability etc.
Low priority: Games and Music.

Thank you!


Browser: Explorer 9
System: Windows
Tagged: , ,

Comments for this Question are closed.

If you are looking for help, please ask a new question here.

We will be happy to help you!

15 Answers -

0 votes

susendeep dutta

July 24, 2012

Looking into your priority,a laptop is the best you can have.But since you already have a laptop,it’s better to have Asus Transformer as it has very good battery life and is very productive too.It will fulfill your priorities.

Denny Lawton

Thankyou

July 24, 2012
0 votes

Dalsan

July 24, 2012

I agree. When using the keyboard dock, you will have a close to laptop experience with the added bonus of touch capabilities and longer battery life. It will offer all the basics you need and then some with the ability to be ultra portable with little need to bring the charger everywhere (up to 18 hours battery life with the keyboard dock, but 13 hours is average for average use). You can easily do basic office documents on the Transformer, and you can easily use a USB keyboard and mouse if need be for more comfort in writing long documents as the smaller size keyboard is cramped. The Transformer is an excellent choice for travel.

0 votes

ferdinan Sitohang

July 25, 2012

if you are looking for a computing device then laptop is the best one for you. But if you are looking a device which can support you 24 hours ON, and what you need is just a simple office and all you need is a simple one, then tablet asus transformer is the best one. May be on top of that, you need to make a priority of what you concern.1. Portable, 24 hours ON and basic office functionality -> Asus transformer. 2. Advance and complex computing -> Toshiba Portege.

0 votes

UD98

July 27, 2012

note that asus is android, toshiba is (windows)

0 votes

UD98

July 27, 2012

depends if you want android over windows

0 votes

Ahmed Saqr

July 28, 2012

Asus Transformer will be perfect for you

0 votes

Kannon Y

July 28, 2012

Something that’s extremely important to note about the Transformer series is that it’s getting an upgrade to Android 4.1, Jellybean, which is the well regarded successor to Icecream Sandwich (4).

The best value out of the Transformer series is the TF300T, which has the same performance as the Prime, but without the Wifi and GPS issues. There’s also the Infinity, which offers a bumped up CPU, but is otherwise a Prime with fewer trademark infringing qualities and a steeper price tag.

However, despite how great a device the Transformer is, most models of Protégé are better for general PC use. If you play PC games, the Protégé is easily better.

The Core i5 (depending on your model) is also many times faster than the Tegra 3 chipset. It’s quite an outstanding laptop build and for the money, is one of the best devices on the market. Also, the Toshiba offers a full Windows operating system rather than Android, which won’t work with anything made in Windows (because they’re different operating systems).

The best feature of the Transformer is that it can double as a tablet and has an 18 hour battery life (as other have mentioned). If that’s an indispensable feature to you, then I’d say that the Transformer is your guy. Otherwise, go with a Protégé. Good luck!

0 votes

Declan Lopez

August 16, 2012

Asus Transformer because of the portability and battery life

0 votes

jrasulev

August 17, 2012

If money is not the issue, laptop is the best option. You will have full featured working machine, not a toy

0 votes

sigits Sigit

August 22, 2012

if the hp pavillion needs are fulfilled, you add the asus transformer. but if the hp pavillion unfulfilled you must choose toshiba portege.

0 votes

fatihamzah

September 3, 2012

ASUS Transformer of course. For Portable. But mind the OS firstly,

0 votes

julien croy

September 7, 2012

Definintily a Toshiba, there very reliable, you get alot for your money. If you don’t like Portege take a look at some of the Satelitte laptops.

0 votes

Umair Adil

October 3, 2012

Toshiba Portege is more reliable than Asus Transformer.

0 votes

Jeremiah Iliffe

October 29, 2012

I would take the Transformer in your situation seeing as you already have a laptop. However if you are looking to upgrade that the Toshiba Protege would be a good option. The ASUS Transformer would probably be better for Games and Music (if casual games) and probably photos as well.

0 votes

Arun Vishnu

December 12, 2012

i give priority to windows devices for all your needs because they are feature rich.but you can countinue with android anyway